VOANews.com

Voice of America - Khmer

 
News in 45 Languages
Duch’s Trial Allays Some, Not All, Concerns


12 May 2009

The ongoing trial of Duch has put to rest many concerns about the Khmer Rouge tribunal and whether it can effectively administer justice to five jailed leaders of the regime.

Dressed in button-up, collared shirts that are far different from the black pajamas and cap he is shown wearing in file photos, Duch has answered many questions about the regime and his role at Tuol Sleng, known as S-21 to the Khmer Rouge.

He has also apologized to his victims and their families. However, for some, the trial has not been enough, and for others, concerns about political bias and corruption in the court remain.

The trial of Duch, whose real name is Kaing Kek Iev, began in earnest March 30, and the former administrator has already admitted to ordering the torture and execution of Khmer Rouge cadre, intellectuals, foreigners, and, in the end, some of the very guards and interrogators who worked under him.

These admissions differ starkly from the hedging, denials and finger-pointing exercised by four other tribunal defendants: ideologue Nuon Chea, head of state Khieu Samphan, foreign minister Ieng Sary, and social affairs minister Ieng Thirith.

None of them has come close to apologizing for the horrors perpetrated by members of their regime, which killed nearly 2 million people through overwork, starvations, disease, torture and execution.

“Please allow me to apologize to those victims who are still alive and to families of the dead for their miserable deaths at S-21,” Duch said during one session of his trial. “Now I would like them to know that I am sorry, so please take this wish into your consideration. I certainly do not beg you all for forgiveness yet.”

He spoke from a prepared statement, and some tribunal observers have wondered at his sincerity. Some of the few survivors of his prison have refused to accept his apology; they want the court to issue a final verdict.

Other monitors say the tribunal has been well organized, and they would like to see the other four defendants follow Duch’s example.

“I have observed that out of the five [detainees], only Duch confessed to doing this or that, but the other four do not confess,” said Kek Galabru, president of the rights group Licadho, which is following the trial. “Duch’s confession helps us to understand that what Duch did was on orders from above.”

However, for Vann Nath, a surviving prisoner of S-21, Duch’s confession was not convincing. He’s also doubtful all the trials will take place.

“The process has been so long,” he told VOA Khmer. “They have now found a way out because it has been too long. They find different tricks. It is also impossible to say that they are wrong. It now goes that way. What can we do?”

He’s not ready for Duch’s apology.

“We are still considering,” he said. “We don’t just agree with what has been said immediately.”

Duch, now 66 and by far the youngest to be indicted, faces charges of war crimes, crimes against humanity, torture and murder, for his role at Tuol Sleng and other facilities. Prosecutors say more than 12,000 prisoners were tortured under his direction and later sent to their deaths at an execution site outside Phnom Penh.

His trial is scheduled to end July 2, but some observers say it could take up to 16 months to complete.

“It is hard to expect a definite date, because, as we know, in a trial there are many parties involved,” tribunal spokesman Reach Sambath said.

Despite much preparation, the UN-backed tribunal has had some difficulty with Duch’s trial.

Challenges of political interference, a lack of funding, and a lack of support for victim participation and outreach remain, Michelle Staggs Kelsall, deputy director of the East-West Centre’s Asian International Justice Initiative, recently told participants of forum in Washington.

Simultaneous translation has been another hurdle. Critics say many of the points are mistranslated from Khmer to English, when Cambodian judges or prosecutors speak.


Download KHMER AUDIO aired 08 May 2009 1.92 MB
Download  (MP3)
Listen to This Report KHMER AUDIO aired 08 May 2009 1.92 MB
Listen (MP3)
E-mail This Article E-mail this article
Print This Article Print Version
  Cambodia News
Cambodia's Garment Workers Hit by Recession  Video clip available

  More Stories
Group Seeks to Keep Cambodian Arts Alive
NGOs Too Lack Resource Protection Capacity  Audio Clip Available
Cambodia Marks Independence Day  Audio Clip Available
Appeals Court Postpones Acid Attack Case  Audio Clip Available
Former King Remembered for Independence Day  Audio Clip Available
Thais Threaten to Close Cambodian Borders  Audio Clip Available
Journalist Handed Two Years for Disinformation  Audio Clip Available
Hun Sen in Tokyo To Discuss Mekong Development  Audio Clip Available
Thais Recall Ambassador Over Thaksin Job  Audio Clip Available
Tribunal Gives Update on Second Investigation  Audio Clip Available
National Budget Risks High Deficits: World Bank  Audio Clip Available
National Power Plan Outdated: Report  Audio Clip Available
Appeals Court Takes Up Acid Attack Case  Audio Clip Available
Thaksin Appointed ‘Adviser’ to Hun Sen  Audio Clip Available
Private Companies Prepare To Enter Stock Exchange  Audio Clip Available
Spirit of Tribunal Honors Victims: Official  Audio Clip Available
Carter To Visit Habitat for Humanity Homes  Audio Clip Available
Water Festival Wraps Up in Capital  Audio Clip Available
Opposition Accused of Border Post Destruction  Audio Clip Available
Thais Protest Over Soldiers on Border  Audio Clip Available
Beehive Radio Owner Dons Monk Robes  Audio Clip Available
Cambodia Mulls Resource Transparency Initiative  Audio Clip Available
‘Peace’ a Legacy of Sihanouk: Official  Audio Clip Available
New Tribunal Budget Anticipates More Indictments  Audio Clip Available
Opposition Lawmaker To Return from US  Audio Clip Available
‘Jungle Girl’ Falls Ill After Return to Forest  Audio Clip Available
Filmmaker Hopes to Bring Justice in Acid Attack  Audio Clip Available
Areas Near Lake Development Now Flooded  Audio Clip Available
Thais To Explain Thaksin Charges to Hun Sen  Audio Clip Available
H1N1 Claims Fourth Cambodian  Audio Clip Available
Katina Worshippers Barred from Remote Pagoda  Audio Clip Available
Sex Trade Continues Despite Laws: Group  Audio Clip Available
Telecoms Ordered to Allow Cross-Network Calls  Audio Clip Available
Appeals Court Upholds Fines for Mu Sochua  Audio Clip Available