News / Asia

Analysts Urge President Obama to Rethink Afghan Strategy

Multimedia

Defending his Afghanistan strategy this week, President Obama said the Afghan war is harder than the war in Iraq, and that key aspects of his troop surge strategy will take time to succeed. But he told a magazine interviewer, the strategy has not failed yet either.

Meanwhile, a group of Afghanistan experts in Washington say Mr. Obama should re-think his strategy, scale back the U.S. military effort, and push for a meaningful political reconciliation.

U.S. military officials say their offensive Afghanistan's Arghendab River Valley has gone exactly as planned. "This is the place we wanted to get into for some time now," said Capt. Nick Stout, a company commander.

So far, there  have been no U.S. or Afghan deaths, at least 20 insurgents have been killed, and U.S. troops now control areas they have never been in before. The only frustration - the Taliban melted away rather than fight.

So now, the the hardest work begins for the troops: winning over a distrustful people who are largely sympathetic to the Taliban.

Meanwhile, President Obama is defending his Afghanistan strategy. He told "Rolling Stone" magazine this week that the strategy has not failed, but that the Afghan war is harder than the war in Iraq, and that key aspects of his troop surge plan will take time to succeed.  

A group of experts on Afghanistan, though, say the President needs to rethink his strategy and scale back the military footprint in the country.

The so-called "Afghanistan Study Group" released a report in Washington which says the large U.S. presence has a negative impact, because it is seen as an occupation force that has motivated the Taliban.

"Our presence also encourages closer cooperation among a disparate array of extremist groups in Afghanistan and Pakistan. We brought the enemies together," said Paul Pillar, a senior analyst with the CIA for 28 years.

The group contends there is a disconnect between the reason the U.S. went to Afghanistan nine years ago and what it is trying to achieve now.

The analysts say the original mission was to permanently destroy al-Qaida hideouts, and they say most of those have now been destroyed.  

They also say al-Qaida is so decentralized right now, it might not want to return. "Even if given the opportunity to return to Afghanistan, it is not at all apparent that (al-Qaida) will see a net advantage in doing so, in comparison to its current presence in Pakistan and its activities elsewhere," said Pillar.

The members of the group do differ on some details. Author and analyst Charles Kupchan, says the U.S. needs to ensure that al-Qaida cannot return. "I think that the claim that al-Qaida would not have a chance to return if the Taliban comes back is perhaps overstated.  I think that there are conditions that we need to have in place to make," he said.

But the group says the U.S. only needs air and naval power to achieve that goal, not a large number of ground troops. It also says any military effort in Afghanistan should be tied to achieving reconciliation among the varous political groups, including the Taliban.

On Tuesday, in fact, Afghan President Hamid Karzai appointed a committee to negotiate peace talks with the Taliban calling for the Taliban to renounce violence and respect the country's constitution.

But the Taliban has dismissed reconciliation talks, saying international forces must first leave Afghanistan.

Matthew Hoh of the New America Foundation says accepting the constitution should not be a condition for talks. And he says the U.S. should support bringing all kinds of Taliban into the mix. Hoh says the U.S. cannot fight its way to its objectives, but can negotiate its way to bring stability and development. "Until you reach some degree of political accord where you bring in those political groups that are now supporting the Taliban because they feel excluded from the government, you will not have stability necessary to achieve anything," he said.

The Afghanistan Study Group says the U.S. is spending almost $100 billion a year in Afghanistan, simply becaU.S.e momentum has pushed it into expanding its role there.

The analysts say that - considering the poor status of the U.S. economy - the Obama administration must make sure the benefits of spending that much money outweigh the cost.

You May Like

Uganda Court Annuls Anti-Gay Law

Court says law was passed in parliament without enough members present for a full quorum More

Multimedia Thailand Makes Efforts to Improve Conditions for Migrant Laborers

In Thailand, its not uncommon for parents to bring their children to work; one company, in-collaboration with other organizations, address safety concerns More

In Indonesia, Jihad Video Raises Concern

Video calls on Indonesians to join Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, ISIL More

This forum has been closed.
Comments
     
There are no comments in this forum. Be first and add one

Featured Videos

Your JavaScript is turned off or you have an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.
In Thailand, Some Efforts to Improve Conditions For Migrant Laborersi
X
Steve Herman
August 01, 2014 6:22 PM
Thailand has been facing increasing international scrutiny as a hub of human trafficking and slave labor. Some of the kingdom’s companies are striving to improve working conditions, especially for the millions of migrant laborers from surrounding countries. VOA Correspondent Steve Herman in Bangkok takes a look at one initiative for children at construction sites
Video

Video In Thailand, Some Efforts to Improve Conditions For Migrant Laborers

Thailand has been facing increasing international scrutiny as a hub of human trafficking and slave labor. Some of the kingdom’s companies are striving to improve working conditions, especially for the millions of migrant laborers from surrounding countries. VOA Correspondent Steve Herman in Bangkok takes a look at one initiative for children at construction sites
Video

Video Public Raises its Voice on Power Plant Pollution

In the United States, proposed rules to cut pollution from the nation’s 600 coal-fired power plants are generating a heated debate. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, charged with writing and implementing the plan, has already received 300,000 written comments. As VOA’s Rosanne Skirble reports, another 1,600 people are lining up this week at EPA headquarters and at satellite offices around the country to give their testimony in person.
Video

Video Information War Rages Alongside Real One in Ukraine

The downing of the Malaysian airliner two weeks ago, and allegations that Russians are shelling Ukrainian troops across the border, have moved the information war swirling around the Ukrainian conflict to a new level. VOA's Al Pessin reports from Kyiv.
Video

Video When Fighting Eases, Gazans Line Up at Bakeries

When there is a lull in the conflict in Gaza, residents who have been hunkered down in their apartments rush out to stock up on food and other necessities. Probably the most important destination is the local bakery. VOA’s Scott Bobb reports from Gaza City.
Video

Video China Investigates Powerful Former Security Chief

The public in China is welcoming the Communist Party's decision to investigate one of the country's once most powerful politicians, former domestic security chief Zhou Yongkang. Analysts say the move by President Xi Jinping is not only an effort to win more support for the party, but an essential step to furthering much needed economic reforms and removing those who would stand in the way of change. VOA's Bill Ide has more from Beijing.
Video

Video US-Funded Program Offers Honduran Children Alternative to Illegal Immigration

President Obama and Central American leaders recently agreed to come up with a plan to address poverty and crime in the region that is fueling the surge of young migrants trying to illegally enter the United States. VOA’s Brian Padden looks at one such program in Honduras - funded in part by the United States - which gives street kids not only food and safety but a chance for a better life without, crossing the border.
Video

Video 'Fab Lab' Igniting Revolution in Kenya

The University of Nairobi’s Science and Technology Park is banking on 3-D prototyping to spark a manufacturing revolution in the country. Lenny Ruvaga has more for from Nairobi's so-called “FabLab” for VOA.
Video

Video Immigrant Influx on Texas Border Heats Up Political Debate

Immigrants from Central America continue to cross the U.S.-Mexico border in south Texas, seeking asylum in the United States, as officials grapple with ways to deal with the problem and provide shelter for thousands of minors among the illegal border crossers. As VOA's Greg Flakus reports from Houston, the issue is complicated by internal U.S. politics and U.S. relations with the troubled nations that immigrants are fleeing.

AppleAndroid