News

Greenhouse Gas Speeded Ice Age Melting

CO2 also plays role in today's warming

This cross section of an ice core from Antarctica tells scientists the history of the ancient atmosphere.
This cross section of an ice core from Antarctica tells scientists the history of the ancient atmosphere.

Multimedia

Audio
Rosanne Skirble

A new study in the Journal Nature provides compelling evidence that carbon dioxide was a major driver of climate change at the end of the last Ice Age.

That correlation supports the prevailing scientific view that that CO2 is also playing a major role in today’s warming global climate.  

The study analyzed ice and sediment samples from dozens of locations on every continent to reconstruct variations in global temperature between 20,000 and 10,000 years ago - the end of the last Ice Age.  

Harvard scientist Jeremy Shakun, the study’s lead author, says climate-change skeptics have long pointed to evidence from Antarctic ice cores that rising levels of C02 in the atmosphere lagged behind the warming climate that marked the end of the Ice Age.

But Shakun says the new study invalidates that argument by correlating CO2 levels and temperatures all across the prehistoric planet.

“So you put these two points together, the correlation of global temperature and CO2, the fact that it lags behind the CO2, and it really leaves you thinking that CO2 was the big driver of global warming at the end of the ice age.”

Other events also helped push the planet out of the ice age. A rare wobble in the Earth’s axis resulted in more sunlight hitting the northern hemisphere. Wind shifted, ice sheets melted, dumping enormous amounts of water into the North Atlantic.

Shakun says the water flow disrupted global ocean circulation and caused a seesawing of heat between the hemispheres.

"Antarctica happens to be on the leading end of the warm end of this seesaw, so it warmed first before the CO2 started to rise," he says. “The key thing to realize with this is that this wasn’t associated with the change in global temperature. The south was warming first, but it was at the expense of cooling in the north or just shifting heat around the planet.”  

Eventually, CO2 released from the deep southern ocean accelerated the warming of the Earth’s atmosphere. Shakun says that ancient story emerges from air bubbles in ice cores, tiny shells in ocean sediment and even pollen at many data points across time.

“We tried to get records that really are pretty highly resolved so it would have a data point on the order of every several decades out to maybe a few centuries. We didn’t pull in any records that only had data point entry of every thousand or two thousand years. That would just be too fuzzy to really answer what we wanted to answer.”      

During the end of the last ice age, as the climate warmed, CO2 levels in the atmosphere rose from about 180 parts per million to about 260.

Shakun says today the CO2 concentration has risen to 392 parts per million - and it’s still climbing.

“We’ve gone up in the last hundred years about 100 ppm (parts per million). That’s on the same order as the amount we rose at the end of the ice age, which I think puts this in perspective. Clearly it’s not a small amount. Obviously rising CO2 at the end of the ice age had a huge effect on global climate, and so we raised it as much in the last century.”   

Shakun doesn’t see this trend ending any time soon unless industrial CO2 emissions are reduced at their source: the burning of fossil fuels in power plants, cars and buildings. He says while the research strengthens the link between C02 and the Ice ages, he believes it also reinforces the importance of addressing C02-driven climate change in our own time.

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments
     
by: Dennis Baker
April 07, 2012 11:33 AM
wow 500 characters to share the solution

no wonder there is a problem


by: Leslie Graham
April 06, 2012 9:00 PM
@ Bunch

I love your "temps have 'only' risen 0.8C" Yeah - in about a century! And you think it's going to stop now?
And by what possible stretch of the imagination do you get your absurd "not enough CO2 in the atmosphere to make any difference in temps" meme.
Did you just make it up on the spur of the moment?


by: luke
April 06, 2012 6:45 PM
In respone to you bunch,
The increase of CO2 causes the greenhouse effect, this is a long-term change on climate, the increase of temperatures out of the last ice age happened over hundreds, even thousands of years. the current situation with manmade climate change isn't going to increase temperatures over 10 years but over hundres of years. we are putting this earth in a bad place in the future.
dont think human time, think geological time. earth time.


by: Bunch
April 06, 2012 3:51 PM
the impetus for the warming was the orbit change of planet earth which started the ice melting in the polar regions and the resulting water vapor included with co2 magnified the warming to end the ice age. without the water vapor (clouds), we would still be in the ice age. not enough co2 in the atmosphere to make any difference in temps, today, or then. we now have twice as much as then and temps have only risen .8C. The conclusions that co2 came before warming is not founded in reality.

Feature Story

Radical protesters, including supporters of the All-Ukrainian Union Svoboda (Freedom) Party, clash with law enforcement members during a rally near the parliament building in Kyiv, October 14, 2014.

Ukraine’s Euromaidan Reforms Reveal Deep Divisions

Activists, nationalists, bureaucrats at odds as nation prepares for key election More

Special Reports