Hong Kong Court Overturns Case Granting Foreign Maids Residency

United Filipinos in Hong Kong chairperson Dolores Balladares, Asian Migrants' Coordinating Body spokesperson Eni Lestari and Association of Indonesian Migrant Workers' representative Ganika Diristiani (from L-R), pose with the court verdict outside the Hi
United Filipinos in Hong Kong chairperson Dolores Balladares, Asian Migrants' Coordinating Body spokesperson Eni Lestari and Association of Indonesian Migrant Workers' representative Ganika Diristiani (from L-R), pose with the court verdict outside the Hi
Ivan Broadhead

The Hong Kong government won a legal appeal Wednesday, overturning the right of foreign domestic workers to claim permanent residency in the southern Chinese city. It's a verdict that advocacy groups describe as discriminatory.

After living and working in Hong Kong for more than a decade, Filipino domestic worker Evangeline Vallejos took the city’s Immigration Department to court last November.

Her aim was to win the same right of permanent abode accorded to thousands of skilled white-collar expats after seven years’ residence - a right defined in Hong Kong’s mini-constitution, the Basic Law.

The High Court found in favor of Vallejos. Its judgment upheld her argument that the Basic Law, effective since Hong Kong’s return to Chinese sovereignty in 1997, applies to all people equally.

However, that verdict was overturned by Hong Kong’s appeal court Wednesday. The court concluded: "It is a fundamental principle that a sovereign state has the power to admit, exclude and expel aliens."

Dolores Balladares is chairwoman of United Filipinos in Hong Kong, a migrant worker advocacy group that supports Vallejos.

"We are very disappointed. It discriminates against foreign domestic workers if others can apply for the right of abode, but why not foreign domestic workers," asks Balladares.

Migrant workers' rights vs. state law

While the terms of employment for migrant workers are significantly better in Hong Kong than other Asian countries, including Singapore and Malaysia, maids are permitted just one statutory day of rest a week and are precluded from Hong Kong’s minimum wage legislation. Instead, they often work 15 hours a day - caring for children, cooking and cleaning - for a basic weekly salary of only $110.

Justice Andrew Leung added in the court’s judgment that their exclusion from the provisions of the Basic Law "is a category of exclusion not different in kind, but only in degree, from the pre-existing categories of excluded persons, for instance, Vietnamese refugees and imprisoned or detained persons."

The November judgment was seen as an important advance in the rights of migrant workers across Asia. It sparked protests, though, among Hong Kong’s indigenous Chinese community.

Of the 300,000 foreign domestic helpers in Hong Kong - predominantly from the Philippines and Indonesia - about 120,000 fulfill the seven-year residency requirement.

However, politicians and community groups argued that far more, perhaps up to half a million people, would be eligible for permanent residency if maids’ dependent relatives were included in the decision.

Estimates suggested it would cost local taxpayers more than $11 billion to pay for the education, health and other social benefits to which these potential new permanent residents would be entitled.

Balladares argues such fears are misplaced.

"We believe the Philippines is our home and really, we want to return there after working here," she said.

Further appeals expected

Secretary for Security Ambrose Lee told reporters that Hong Kong would continue to suspend the 900 applications for permanent abode already made by migrant workers after the November decision. He said he also expected Vallejos to take her case to the Court of Final Appeal.

"Therefore at this stage, the government will not regard the judgment as a final determination of the relevant legal issue," said Lee.

Should Vallejos prevail at the Court of Final Appeal, Lee did not preclude amending the Basic Law, a constitutional process that would require the involvement of the central government in Beijing.

"There are lots of comments on [re]interpretation of the Basic Law by the Standing Committee of the People’s Congress. These are very controversial issues. The amendment of the Basic Law is not yet on our horizon," said Lee.

Approaching Beijing to resolve the abode question would be widely unpopular among a public that fiercely guards its judicial independence from China under the principle of one country, two systems.

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
by: Jonathan Huang
March 28, 2012 7:11 PM
last time I checked HK is not an immigrant city. HK is already saturated, even Chinese are hard to resident there, no need to mention Filipinos.

by: Steve Fraser
March 28, 2012 3:18 PM
This is useless and pointless case. At the end, BeiJing has the final say regarding this matter. Why waste $$$$ on this thing when you well know the result will not be favourable. It is pure stupidity for filipinos and indonesians to fight a losing battle. Mark Daly is just taking advantage of these group of people.

Featured Videos

Your JavaScript is turned off or you have an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.
Rolling Thunder Run Reveals Changed Attitudes Towards Vietnam Wari
Katherine Gypson
May 25, 2015 1:32 AM
For many US war veterans, the Memorial Day holiday is an opportunity to look back at a divisive conflict in the nation’s history and to remember those who did not make it home.

Video Rolling Thunder Run Reveals Changed Attitudes Towards Vietnam War

For many US war veterans, the Memorial Day holiday is an opportunity to look back at a divisive conflict in the nation’s history and to remember those who did not make it home.

Video Female American Soldiers: Healing Through Filmmaking

According to the United States Defense Department, there are more than 200-thousand women serving in the U.S. Armed Forces.  Like their male counterparts, females have experiences that can be very traumatic.  VOA's Bernard Shusman tells us about a program that is helping some American women in the military heal through filmmaking.

Video Iowa Family's Sacrifice Shaped US Military Service for Generations

Few places in America have experienced war like Waterloo. This small town in the Midwest state of Iowa became famous during World War II not for what it accomplished, but what it lost. As VOA’s Kane Farabaugh reports, the legacy of one family’s sacrifice is still a reminder today of the real cost of war for all families on the homefront.

Video On Film: How Dance Defies Iran's Political Oppression

'Desert Dancer' by filmmaker Richard Raymond is based on the true story of a group of young Iranians, who form an underground dance troupe in the Islamic Republic of Iran. This is the latest in a genre of films that focus on dance as a form of freedom of expression against political oppression and social injustice. VOA’s Penelope Poulou has more.

Video Turkey's Ruling Party Trying to Lure Voters in Opposition Stronghold

Turkey’s AK (Justice and Development) Party is seeking a fourth successive general election victory, with the goal of securing two-thirds of the seats in Parliament to rewrite the constitution and change the country's parliamentary system into a presidential one. To achieve that, the party will need to win seats in opposition strongholds like the western city of Izmir. Dorian Jones reports.

Video Millions Flock to Ethiopia Polls

Millions of Ethiopians cast their votes Sunday in the first national election since the 2012 death of longtime leader Meles Zenawi. Mr. Meles' party, the Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front, is almost certain of victory again. VOA's Anita Powell reports from Addis Ababa.

Video Scientists Testing Space Propulsion by Light

Can the sun - the heart of our solar system - power a spacecraft to the edge of our solar system? The answer may come from a just-launched small satellite designed to test the efficiency of solar sail propulsion. Once deployed, its large sail will catch the so-called solar wind and slowly reach what scientists hope to be substantial speed. VOA’s George Putic reports.

Video FIFA Trains Somali Referees

As stability returns to the once lawless nation of Somalia, the world football governing body, FIFA, is helping to rebuild the country’s sport sector by training referees as well as its young footballers. Abdulaziz Billow has more from Mogadishu.

Video With US Child Obesity Rates on the Rise, Program Promotes Health Eating

In its fifth year, FoodCorps puts more than 180 young Americans into 500 schools across the United States, where they focus on teaching students about nutrition, engaging them with hands-on activities, and improving their access to healthy foods whether in the cafeteria or the greater community. Aru Pande has more.

Video Virginia Neighborhood Draws People to Nostalgic Main Street

In the U.S., people used to grow up in small towns with a main street lined by family-owned shops and restaurants. Today, however, many main streets are worn down and empty because shoppers have been lured away by shopping malls. But in the Del Ray neighborhood of Alexandria, Virginia, main street is thriving. VOA’s Deborah Block reports it has a nostalgic feel with its small restaurants and unique stores.

VOA Blogs