News / USA

Supreme Court: US Muslim Cannot Sue Former Official

Abdullah al-Kidd (file photo)
Abdullah al-Kidd (file photo)
Kent Klein

The nation’s highest court has rejected a lawsuit against a former U.S. attorney general over the arrest of an American Muslim who says he was wrongly detained for more than two weeks as the U.S. government pursued the post 9/11 "war on terror." The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that Abdullah al-Kidd cannot personally sue former Attorney General John Ashcroft.  

Abdullah al-Kidd was arrested at Washington Dulles International Airport in 2003 and released 16 days later without being charged. After being freed from jail, he was held under supervised release for another 14 months.

Al-Kidd was held as a material witness under a federal law. The purpose of the law was to compel witnesses to testify in court.

Al-Kidd said that instead of being treated as a potential witness, he was strip-searched, kept in shackles and questioned without an attorney present.

The American Civil Liberties Union, which represented al-Kidd, argued that the law was used improperly to keep their client in custody while federal agents investigated.

A federal court [the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals] agreed, ruling that al-Kidd’s lawsuit against Ashcroft could go forward, and denying the former attorney general’s request for immunity.

Tuesday’s Supreme Court ruling overturned that decision.

Justice Antonin Scalia wrote for the majority, “Qualified immunity gives government officials breathing room to make reasonable but mistaken judgments about open legal questions.”

A law professor at the American University College of Law, Stephen Vladeck, said the justices agreed unanimously that Ashcroft could not be sued personally. And a majority also rejected the merits of al-Kidd's case.

“The majority, led by Justice [Antonin] Scalia, went out of its way to say that even with immunity, al-Kidd could not have won on the merits, because Ashcroft did not, in fact, violate his Fourth Amendment [constitutional] rights.”

Vladeck said it was a narrow ruling, which is not likely to have a broad effect on future government efforts to prosecute terrorism suspects.

“That is unfortunate for al-Kidd, but insofar as broader legal developments going forward, I suspect this decision will actually have a negligible impact,” he said.

The professor said the ruling was the latest in a decade-long trend in court decisions. According to Vladeck, damage suits against the government arising out of counterterrorism policies have been difficult to pursue.

“This decision, like many of the decisions before it, really does not put that much of a deterrent on this or any future government when it comes to aggressive counterterrorism policies, and I think that may be where there is matter for concern,” said Vladeck.

Eight of the nine justices took part in the ruling. Justice Elena Kagan did not participate, because she had served as the Obama administration’s solicitor general before being named to the high court.

You May Like

Key Al-Shabab Commander Captured

Zakariye Ismail Hersi was captured in a raid Saturday morning in the town of El Wak near the border with Kenya More

Relations Between Pakistan, Afghanistan Key to Fighting Taliban

A Pakistani official tells VOA that anti-terrorism campaign has resulted in improved counter-terrorism cooperation with Afghanistan More

160,000 Displaced by Flooding in Malaysia

Prime Minister Najib Razak visits hard-hit Kelantan state, announces nearly $145M in additional relief for victims More

This forum has been closed.
Comments
     
There are no comments in this forum. Be first and add one

Featured Videos

Your JavaScript is turned off or you have an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.
Estimates Rising of Foreign Fighters in Iraq, Syriai
X
Jeff Seldin
December 24, 2014 11:38 PM
Foreign fighters are making more of a mark on the battles raging across Syria and Iraq than initially thought. VOA's Jeff Seldin has more.
Video

Video Estimates Rising of Foreign Fighters in Iraq, Syria

Foreign fighters are making more of a mark on the battles raging across Syria and Iraq than initially thought. VOA's Jeff Seldin has more.
Video

Video Russians Head Into Holiday Facing Economic Malaise

Russian preparations for the New Year holiday are clouded by economic recession and a tumbling currency, the ruble. Nonetheless, people in the Russian capital appear to be in a festive mood. VOA's Daniel Schearf reports from Moscow.
Video

Video Mombasa in Holiday Tourism Slump Due to Security Fears

Kenya's usually popular beachside tourist destination of Mombasa is seeing a much slower holiday season this year due to fears of insecurity as the country has suffered from a string of terror attacks linked to Somali militants. Mohammed Yusuf reports for VOA on how businessmen and tourists feel about the situation.
Video

Video For Somalis, 2014 Marked by Political Instability Within Government

While Somalia has long been torn apart by warfare and violence, this year one of the country's biggest challenges has come from within the government, as political infighting curtails the country's progress, threatens security gains and disappoints the international community. VOA's Gabe Joselow report.
Video

Video US Political Shift Could Affect Iran Nuclear Talks

Secretary of State John Kerry’s efforts to resolve Iran’s nuclear crisis are continuing into 2015 after Iran and six world powers failed to agree by a November deadline. U.S. domestic politics, however, could complicate efforts to reach a deal in the new year. VOA State Department correspondent Pam Dockins has the story.
Video

Video NYSE: The Icon of Capitalism

From its humble beginnings in 1792 to its status as an economic bellweather for the world, the New York Stock Exchange is an integral part of the story of America. VOA’s Bernard Shusman reports from Wall Street.
Video

Video Islamic State Emergence Transforms Syria and Iraq in 2014

The emergence of the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria as a potent force in early 2014 changed the dynamics of the region. Their brutal methods - including executions and forced slavery - horrified the international community, drawing Western forces into the conflict. It also splintered the war in Syria, where more than 200,000 Syrians have died in the conflict. VOA’s Henry Ridgwell looks back at a deadly year in the region -- and what 2015 may hold.
Video

Video Massive Study Provides Best Look at Greenland Ice Loss Yet

The Greenland ice sheet is melting faster than predicted, according to a new study released in the Proceedings of the National Academic of Sciences that combines NASA satellite data and aerial missions. As VOA’s Rosanne Skirble reports, the finding means coastal communities worldwide could be at greater risk, sooner, from the impact of rising seas.
Video

Video US Marines, Toys for Tots Bring Christmas Joy

Christmas is a time for giving in the United States, especially to young children who look forward to getting presents. But some families don't have money to buy gifts. For nearly 70 years, a U.S. Marines-sponsored program has donated toys and distributed them to underprivileged children during the holiday season. VOA's Deborah Block tells us about the annual Toys for Tots program.
Video

Video France Rocked by Attacks as Fear of ISIS-Inspired Terror Grows

Eleven people were injured, two seriously, when a man drove his car into crowds of pedestrians Sunday night in the French city of Dijon, shouting ‘God is Great’ in Arabic. It’s the latest in a series of apparent ‘lone-wolf’ terror attacks in the West. Henry Ridgwell looks at the growing threat of attacks, which security experts say are likely inspired by the so-called "Islamic State" terror group.

Circumventing Censorship

An Internet Primer for Healthy Web Habits

As surveillance and censoring technologies advance, so, too, do new tools for your computer or mobile device that help protect your privacy and break through Internet censorship.
More

All About America

AppleAndroid