News / USA

Supreme Court: US Muslim Cannot Sue Former Official

Abdullah al-Kidd (file photo)
Abdullah al-Kidd (file photo)
Kent Klein

The nation’s highest court has rejected a lawsuit against a former U.S. attorney general over the arrest of an American Muslim who says he was wrongly detained for more than two weeks as the U.S. government pursued the post 9/11 "war on terror." The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that Abdullah al-Kidd cannot personally sue former Attorney General John Ashcroft.  

Abdullah al-Kidd was arrested at Washington Dulles International Airport in 2003 and released 16 days later without being charged. After being freed from jail, he was held under supervised release for another 14 months.

Al-Kidd was held as a material witness under a federal law. The purpose of the law was to compel witnesses to testify in court.

Al-Kidd said that instead of being treated as a potential witness, he was strip-searched, kept in shackles and questioned without an attorney present.

The American Civil Liberties Union, which represented al-Kidd, argued that the law was used improperly to keep their client in custody while federal agents investigated.

A federal court [the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals] agreed, ruling that al-Kidd’s lawsuit against Ashcroft could go forward, and denying the former attorney general’s request for immunity.

Tuesday’s Supreme Court ruling overturned that decision.

Justice Antonin Scalia wrote for the majority, “Qualified immunity gives government officials breathing room to make reasonable but mistaken judgments about open legal questions.”

A law professor at the American University College of Law, Stephen Vladeck, said the justices agreed unanimously that Ashcroft could not be sued personally. And a majority also rejected the merits of al-Kidd's case.

“The majority, led by Justice [Antonin] Scalia, went out of its way to say that even with immunity, al-Kidd could not have won on the merits, because Ashcroft did not, in fact, violate his Fourth Amendment [constitutional] rights.”

Vladeck said it was a narrow ruling, which is not likely to have a broad effect on future government efforts to prosecute terrorism suspects.

“That is unfortunate for al-Kidd, but insofar as broader legal developments going forward, I suspect this decision will actually have a negligible impact,” he said.

The professor said the ruling was the latest in a decade-long trend in court decisions. According to Vladeck, damage suits against the government arising out of counterterrorism policies have been difficult to pursue.

“This decision, like many of the decisions before it, really does not put that much of a deterrent on this or any future government when it comes to aggressive counterterrorism policies, and I think that may be where there is matter for concern,” said Vladeck.

Eight of the nine justices took part in the ruling. Justice Elena Kagan did not participate, because she had served as the Obama administration’s solicitor general before being named to the high court.

You May Like

Video Obama Announces Plan to Send 3,000 Troops to Liberia in Ebola Fight

At US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Obama details troop deployment and other pieces of US plan More

Video China Muslims Work to Change Perceptions After Knife Attacks

Muslims in Kunming say that they condemn the violence, it is not a reflection of the true beliefs of their faith More

Humanitarian Aid, Equipment Blocked in Cameroon

Move is seen as a developing supply crisis in West Africa More

This forum has been closed.
Comments
     
There are no comments in this forum. Be first and add one

Featured Videos

Your JavaScript is turned off or you have an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.
Enviropreneur Seeks to Save the Environment, Empower the Communityi
X
September 16, 2014 2:06 PM
Lorna Rutto, a former banker, is now an ‘enviropreneur’ - turning plastic waste into furniture and fences discusses the challenges she faces in Africa with raw materials and the environment.
Video

Video Enviropreneur Seeks to Save the Environment, Empower the Community

Lorna Rutto, a former banker, is now an ‘enviropreneur’ - turning plastic waste into furniture and fences discusses the challenges she faces in Africa with raw materials and the environment.
Video

Video West Trades Accusations Over Ransoms

As world leaders try to forge a common response to the threat posed by Islamic State militants in Iraq and Syria, there is simmering tension over differing policies on paying ransoms. In the past month, the jihadist group has beheaded two Americans and one Briton. Both countries refuse to pay ransom money. As Henry Ridgwell reports for VOA from London, there is uncertainty in the approach of some other European nations.
Video

Video Scotland Independence Bid Stokes Global Interest

The people of Scotland are preparing to vote on whether to become independent and break away from the rest of Britain, in a referendum being watched carefully in many other countries. Some see it as a risky experiment; while others hope a successful vote for independence might energize their own separatist demands. Foreign immigrants to Scotland have a front row seat for the vote. VOA’s Henry Ridgwell spoke to some of them in Edinburgh.
Video

Video Washington DC Mural Artists Help Beautify City

Like many cities, Washington has a graffiti problem. Buildings and homes, especially in low-income neighborhoods, are often targets of illegal artwork. But as we hear from VOA’s Julie Taboh, officials in the nation's capital have come up with an innovative program that uses the talents of local artists to beautify the city.
Video

Video US Muslim Leaders Condemn Islamic State

Leaders of America's Muslim community are condemning the violent extremism of the Islamic State group in Iraq and Syria. The U.S. Muslim leaders say militants are exploiting their faith in a failed effort to justify violent extremism. VOA correspondent Meredith Buel reports.
Video

Video Americans' Reaction Mixed on Obama Strategy for Islamic State Militants

President Barack Obama’s televised speech on how the United States plans to “degrade and destroy” the group known as the Islamic State reached a prime-time audience of millions. And it came as Americans appear more willing to embrace a bolder, tougher approach to foreign policy. VOA producer Katherine Gypson and reporter Jeff Seldin have this report from Washington.
Video

Video Authorities Allege LA Fashion Industry-Cartel Ties

U.S. officials say they have broken up crime rings that funneled tens of millions of dollars from Mexican drug cartels through fashion businesses in Los Angeles. Mike O'Sullivan reports that authorities announced nine arrests, as 1,000 law enforcement agents fanned out through the city on Wednesday.
Video

Video Bedouin Woman Runs Successful Business in Palestinian City

A Bedouin woman is breaking social taboos by running a successful vacation resort in the Palestinian town of Jericho. Bedouins are a sub-group of Arabs known for their semi-nomadic lifestyle. Zlatica Hoke says the resort in the West Bank's Jordan Valley is a model of success for women in the region.


Carnage and mayhem are part of daily life in northern Nigeria, the result of a terror campaign by the Islamist group Boko Haram. Fears are growing that Nigeria’s government may not know how to counter it, and may be making things worse. More

AppleAndroid