Text Only
Search

 
US Senate Prepares for Confirmation Process for High Court Nominee


20 July 2005
Tate report (Real Media) - Download 415k - Download (Real) audio clip
Tate report (Real Media) - Download 415k - Listen (Real) audio clip

Judge Roberts speaking after his nomination Tuesday night 19 July 2005
Judge Roberts speaking after his nomination Tuesday
Members of the U.S. Senate are beginning to examine the record of President Bush's nominee to the Supreme Court, Judge John Roberts, as they prepare for confirmation hearings, which could begin as early as next month. Judge Roberts met with Senate leaders and members of the Judiciary Committee Wednesday.

Under Article II, Section II of the U.S. Constitution, the Senate has the responsibility to advise the president about nominees and the authority to approve or reject them.

Senators are taking their advise-and-consent responsibility seriously. They acknowledge that Supreme Court justices are the final arbiters on issues that can affect all aspects of daily life. They also note that the justices serve for life, or until they decide to retire, and thus their influence can last for decades.

A day after President Bush announced his decision to name Judge Roberts to the high court, Republicans praised the nominee, saying he would be a fair, open-minded and impartial member of the Supreme Court.

"I believe Judge Roberts is exactly the kind of Justice America expects on the Supreme Court. He is among the best of the best legal minds in America," said Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist.

Republicans hope for quick confirmation, noting that the Senate two years ago confirmed Judge Roberts to the appeals court.

Democrats, including Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid, agree that Judge Roberts is a man of intellect and good character, but they are reserving judgment on his fitness for a seat on the Supreme Court.

"All these are important qualities, but they do not automatically qualify John Roberts to serve on the highest court in the land. Nor does the fact that he has been confirmed to serve on the court of appeals mean that he is entitled to be automatically promoted," he said.

Senator Ted Kennedy is a member of the Judiciary Committee who voted against sending Judge Roberts' appeals court nomination to the full Senate two years ago. He expressed concern about the nominee's commitment to individual rights, and referred to a brief Judge Roberts co-wrote in 1990 that suggested the landmark Supreme Court case, Roe v. Wade, which legalized abortion, should be overturned.

"He opposed programs to guarantee equal opportunity, he opposed the right to privacy, and argued to overturn the Roe v.Wade, saying the case was wrongly decided," Sen. Kennedy said.

Democrats are vowing to press Judge Roberts to explain his views on civil rights, abortion and other matters, and say they will demand full answers to their questions about his rulings, statements, writings and judicial views.

Although Republicans hold 55 of the 100 seats in the Senate, Democrats could block the nomination from coming to a vote, as they have done with 10 of President Bush's judicial nominees. But it is not clear if they will pursue such parliamentary tactics.

Senator Arlen Specter, the Republican chairman of the Judiciary Committee, hopes they do not.

"I am hoping it will not be a partisan battle, that it will be, as the president requested, a dignified, courteous proceeding, where we take a look at Judge Robert's background, his jurisprudence in detail, his professionalism, and make up our minds," he said.

President Bush would like Judge Roberts sworn in by the time the Supreme Court reconvenes on October 3.

If confirmed, Judge Roberts, a 50-year-old conservative, would replace retiring Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, a moderate conservative who often cast the swing vote on the nine-member court.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Roberts Nomination Could Have Significant Impact on US Supreme Court
Bush Nominee Has History Before Supreme Court
Bush Says Supreme Court Confirmation Process Off to Good Start
Bush Nominates Federal Judge John Roberts to Supreme Court
 
  Top Story
Russian General: Withdrawal from Georgia to Take 10 Days  Audio Clip Available

  More Stories
Taliban Claims Responsibility for  Pakistan Bombings  Audio Clip Available
Russia Suspends Cooperation With NATO  Audio Clip Available
US, Iraq Close to Agreement on US Troop Withdrawal
Israel Warns Against US, International Pressure for Palestinian Agreement  Audio Clip Available
US Sees Prospect of Better Relations With Belarus
Zimbabwean Opposition Warns Convening Parliament Violates Power-Sharing Deal  Audio Clip Available
Somalia Peace Deal Jeopardized by Continuing Violence
Darfurian Refugees in CAR Receive Welcome in Village Not Camps  Audio Clip Available
Chinese Police Sentence 6 Foreigners to 10 Days Detention
Experts Debate Legacy of Beijing Olympics  Audio Clip Available