Text Only
Search

 
Republicans, Democrats Continue to Exchange Words Over Question of Pre-War Intelligence


09 November 2005
Robinson report - Download 327k - Download (Real) audio clip
Robinson report - Download 327k - Listen (Real) audio clip

The origins of the war in Iraq were debated Wednesday by a key congressional panel as Democrats and Republicans continue to exchange words over the question of pre-war intelligence.

The debate took place as the House International Relations Committee considered a resolution of inquiry demanding that the Bush administration turn over documents Democrats say would provide a clearer picture of how intelligence was used in the months leading to the Iraq war.

A resolution of inquiry is a rare House [of Representatives] procedure lawmakers can use to obtain documents and other information from the executive branch of government.

In recent months, Democrats have used this legislative tactic as they accused Republicans of failing to adequately investigate pre-war intelligence, and the controversial case involving the leaking of the identity of a CIA officer whose husband is a critic of administration justifications for going to war.

Republicans have long argued that everyone who supported military action in the months leading to Congress approving a key resolution in late 2002 did so on the basis of the same available intelligence, noting that many key Democrats voted for the war.

Republicans argue that many Democrats had accepted the thinking that Saddam Hussein posed a threat and that he was pursuing weapons of mass destruction.

Based on this, committee chairman Congressman Henry Hyde argued strenuously against the Democratic resolution.

"I think this is a political effort to embarrass the president," said Mr. Hyde.  "I don't care how we got into the war, that we will have to argue until doomsday.  But one thing I do know, we'd better win.  We'd better not lose this war.  We'd better not get chased out of the Middle East.  And if that happens it will be a disaster."

Democratic Congressman Robert Menendez responded that Congress has an obligation to seek all the information it can obtain about the reasons underlying the Bush administration decision to go to war in Iraq.

"It is past time for Congress to take back its right to act as a check and balance against the executive," said Mr. Menendez.  "It is past time for Congress to fulfill its obligation to the American people and demand information on the Iraq war and the leaking of the name of a CIA operative.  It is past time for Congress to fulfill its responsibility to oversee the president and the executive branch."

As has been the case when similar resolutions came before Republican controlled committees, the Democratic proposal was voted down, this time by a vote of 25 to 23.

The vote by the committee, which will send the resolution to the full House of Representatives with what is called an unfavorable recommendation, virtually assures the Democratic initiative will not go any further.

The resolution of inquiry sought documents, emails and other records relating to the White House Iraq Group, which consisted of a number of officials who were the driving force behind President Bush's determination to invade Iraq on the basis of weapons of mass destruction.

Officials named in the resolution included Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice, Andrew Card and Karl Rove, White House Chief of Staff and Deputy Chief of Staff respectively, and I. Lewis Libby, who has been indicted in connection with the case involving a leak of the identity of a CIA officer, Valerie Plame.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Chalabi Denies Passing Faulty Pre-War Information on Iraq
Chalabi in Washington for Meetings, Speech
US, Iraqi Forces Clear Insurgents from Border Town
 
  Top Story
Israel Opens Up Humanitarian Corridors in Gaza as Fighting Continues  Audio Clip Available

  More Stories
Photographer Nick Ut:  Witness to History
Egypt Proposes Israel-Palestinian Cease-Fire
Israel Welcomes Truce Plan for Gaza, but Does Not Accept It Yet
Russia Cuts All Gas to Ukraine as Europe Shivers  Audio Clip Available
New State Government Takes Power in Kashmir  Audio Clip Available
Sri Lanka Reinstates Ban on Tamil Rebels
Ghana Inaugurates New President
Ping Pong Match Commemorates US-China 'Ping Pong Diplomacy'  Audio Clip Available
Bush, Obama Have Lunch With Former US Presidents
Zimbabwe's Mugabe Appoints Temporary Ministers  Audio Clip Available
Shi'ites Mark Ashura in Iraq
Obama Appoints New Officer to Get Rid of Government Waste
Controversy Arises Over Alleged Hamas-Iran Ties  Audio Clip Available
US House Democrats, Republicans Pledge Bipartisanship  Audio Clip Available
Korean Retail Giant Joins Australian Wool Boycott  Audio Clip Available
Rajasthan's Camel Trade Faces Changing Times  Audio Clip Available