Text Only
Search

 
Pipelines Sow Political Goodwill and Generate Controversy


24 March 2005
Thomas report (Real Player) - Download 494k - Download (Real) audio clip
Thomas report (Real Player) - Download 494k - Listen (Real) audio clip

voa OSullivan anwr transalaskapipeline 150 04sep01.jpg
The vast networks of pipelines that carry oil and natural gas around the globe bring more than just economic benefits. In some cases, they can foster better relations between countries. In other cases, they can strain ties.

It is a mathematical axiom that the shortest distance between two points is a straight line. But when building a pipeline, the shortest distance is sometimes sacrificed, and builders may be forced through an environmental or even political maze.

Robert Ebel, chair of the energy program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, says that pipelines can drive wedges between nations, but they can also bring them closer together.

"Pipelines do bind nations together," he said. "The producer nations, the importer nations, the transit countries - all are interested in seeing to it that that pipeline is built on time, and that it operates without any problems because all would benefit. So there's that economic link, and there's a political link."

 

But the political link sometimes poses problems. One example is the proposal to build a pipeline to bring natural gas from the Caspian Sea to India, whose economic growth is fueling new demands for energy. One idea is to run the pipeline from Iran through Pakistan to India. But the U.S. government, currently at odds with Teheran over Iran's alleged nuclear ambitions, is keen not to give Iran any economic benefit.

Condoleezza Rice, left, is greeted by Indian FM Natwar Singh in New Delhi

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice made that clear during a recent joint appearance before reporters with Indian Foreign Minister Natwar Singh.

"We have communicated to the Indian government our concerns about gas pipeline cooperation between Iran and India," she said. "I think our ambassador has made statements in that regard. And so those concerns are well-known to the Indian government."

But India does not share those concerns. Mr. Singh said India believes Iran will live up to its commitments under the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty - a confidence not shared by the United States.

"We have traditional good relations with Iran," he said. "We expect Iran will fulfill all its obligations with regard to the NPT. We have no problems of any kind with Iran."

A pipeline bringing gas to India could also go through Afghanistan. But it would have to pass through Pakistan - India's neighbor and arch rival. At the recent World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, Pakistani Prime Minister Shaukat Aziz said what he dubbed the "peace pipeline" will do much to heal the long-standing Indo-Pakistani rift.

"What we are trying to do is use this to meet our energy needs, but also to create interdependencies between countries because we firmly believe that if you create the linkages and interdependencies, you can push the peace process forward, much stronger," he said. "So if we do this pipeline and it does take off, I sincerely believe India-Pakistan relations will move forward in the right direction."

As Gal Luft, director of the Institute for Analysis of Global Security, points out, the economic benefits that transit countries like Pakistan or Afghanistan can enjoy also play into the political equations.

"Those countries make a lot of money by having the pipeline run through their territory. It's called transit fees, which could go all the way up to 20 or 30 or 40 cents per barrel, and sometimes even more," he said. "And for a lot of those countries, this provides a source of revenue, and therefore they would like to be involved in such projects."

For countries like Afghanistan and Pakistan, such transit revenues make a pipeline a lifeline to a battered economy.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Analysts: Pipelines Used as Diplomatic Tools and Targets for Terrorists
Higher Oil Prices Make New Pipeline Construction More Likely
US Concerned About India-Iran Pipeline Project
 
  Top Story
Obama Pays Tribute to Fort Hood Shooting Victims   Audio Clip Available  Video clip available

  More Stories
Details Emerge About Alleged Fort Hood Shooter  Audio Clip Available  Video clip available
Bomb Rocks Northwestern Pakistan
China Ready to Welcome President Obama  Video clip available
US Urges North Korea Not to Escalate Tensions in Yellow Sea
British PM Defends Military Mission in Afghanistan  Audio Clip Available
Lebanon's Unity Government Convenes for First Time
Tropical Storm Ida Downgraded; Moves Inland
Report: Africa's Disappearing Wetlands Produce 'Alarming' Levels of Greenhouse Gas
IEA Urges Action on Climate Change
Somali Pirates Deny Arms Seizure  Audio Clip Available
Cross-Examination Begins in War Crimes Trial of Former Liberian President  Audio Clip Available
US Development of H1N1 Vaccine Hits Snag  Video clip available
Asia to Welcome President Obama  Video clip available
Obama Makes First China Tour as Economic Interdependence Grows  Audio Clip Available  Video clip available
APEC Marks 20 Years, Looks to Future of Regional Trade  Audio Clip Available
Clinton Urges 'Compassion' for Americans Detained in Iran  Audio Clip Available
World War II Museum Expansion Aims at Younger Generations  Audio Clip Available  Video clip available
North Carolina World War II Veterans Honored in Washington  Video clip available