Text Only
Search

 
Russia Investigates Mini-Sub Incident


08 August 2005

Russia is launching an investigation into the Navy's response to the stranding of a mini-sub at the bottom of the Pacific that was rescued Sunday with British help. The memory of the Kursk nuclear submarine accident five years ago, in which 118 people died is still fresh, and the government is drawing criticism for its handling of the rescue.

Defense Minister Sergei Ivanov
Defense Minister Sergei Ivanov
Russian Defense Minister Sergei Ivanov Monday visited the seven people who were rescued from the mini-sub Sunday, after three days stranded on the ocean floor off Russia's far-eastern coast, and only hours, officials say, before they would have run out of oxygen.

Mr. Ivanov commended the sailors for their bravery, and said the Russian Navy would have all the technical equipment and material it needs in the future.

Later, addressing reporters in the Russian Far East, he said President Vladimir Putin had ordered a full-scale investigation of the incident off the Kamchatka Peninsula.

In comments broadcast on Russian television, Mr. Ivanov says the expert commission will examine thoroughly the actions of fleet forces and defense ministry officials. He also said that the Russian Navy's second-in-command, Vladimir Masorin, would lead the investigation of how the small submarine came to be trapped under water for three days.

A British underwater rescue vehicle helped lift the sub to the surface on Sunday, and all seven sailors on board were rushed to the hospital. There they were placed in cardiac care, due to hypothermia and hypoxia, and are expected to remain under close watch for three days.

The sailors' close brush with death has many in Russia asking why it was necessary to ask for foreign help. There are also questions as to how and why it happened a second time. This month marks the five-year anniversary of the sinking of the nuclear submarine Kursk with 118 hands on board.

Leading independent military analyst Pavel Felgenhauer tells VOA that, unlike in the Kursk tragedy, Russian officials this time called for outside help in time. But still, he says the main lesson of the Kursk has yet to be learned, and that, he says, is that Russia must have an adequate search and rescue service of its own.

"There was a lot of talk, but nothing really improved operationally," said Mr. Felgenhauer. "Again, right now, there is a lot of talk, but no one can be sure that this talk will transform into real, adequate action."

Until that lesson is learned, Mr. Felgenhauer adds, Russia will be, as he put it, "hopelessly helpless." He also said he holds out little hope for this latest official probe.

"The problem is, it's going to be a closed military investigation," he said. "We will not know what they determine. It will all be covered with a cloak of secrecy. There will be no parliamentary open inquiries, there will be nothing really published, and, basically, I believe, the navy and the military will do their best to sort of sweep it all under the carpet."

The Russian press was equally critical Monday. The Gazeta daily said on its front page that no one had learned the lessons from the Kursk. The newspaper went on to say that, only when the situation was near critical, did the navy's top leadership ask for outside help.

"It wasn't our victory," wrote another popular daily, Moskovsky Komsomolets.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Seven Russian Sailors Safe After Submarine Rescue
 
  Top Story
Berlin to Mark the 20th Anniversary of the Fall of the Berlin Wall  Audio Clip Available  Video clip available

  More Stories
Suicide Bomber Kills 3 in Northwestern Pakistan
APEC Economies Report Improved Trade Finance, Discuss Free Trade  Audio Clip Available
Israel's Netanyahu, Obama to Meet Monday
Scientists Report Abnormal Sea Level Rises Off Western Australia  Audio Clip Available
Obama: Iraq Election Law an "Important Milestone"  Audio Clip Available
Iraqi Parliament Approves New Electoral Law After Raucous Debate  Audio Clip Available
US Army Chief of Staff: More Troops Needed in Afghanistan
Market Bomber Kills 13 in Northwest Pakistan
Clinton Urges Europeans to Bring Down "Walls" of Terrorism, Oppression  Audio Clip Available
Hurricane Ida Heads Toward Gulf of Mexico, Floods Kill 91 in El Salvador
Russia-Iran Relations Balancing on Nuclear Issue
Motive Sought for Texas Mass Shooting
Dalai Lama Rejects Chinese Criticism of Monastery Visit  Audio Clip Available
China's Premier Pledges $10 billion in Loans to Africa  Audio Clip Available
Netanyahu Heads to US Amid Crisis in Peace Process  Audio Clip Available
Japan Pledges More Aid to Burma if Political Prisoners are Released
WFP Making Inroads on Alleviating Hunger  Audio Clip Available
Deposed Madagascar President says He Will Work With Rival Who Ousted Him  Audio Clip Available
US Health Care Debate Continues on Partisan Lines