Text Only
Search

 
Supreme Court Nominee Pledges Open Mind if Confirmed


12 September 2005
Tate report - Download 312k - Download (Real) audio clip
Tate report - Download 312k - Listen (Real) audio clip

Judge John G. Roberts raises his right hand as he is sworn in before the Senate Judiciary Committee to testify on his confirmation to become the chief justice
Judge John G. Roberts raises his right hand as he is sworn in before the Senate Judiciary Committee to testify on his confirmation to become the chief justice
President Bush's nominee to be chief justice of the U.S. Supreme Court is vowing to keep an open mind if confirmed by the Senate.  Judge John Roberts made his comments on the first day of confirmation hearings before the Senate Judiciary Committee.

In a brief opening statement, Judge Roberts said he has no agenda for the Supreme Court:

"If I am confirmed, I will confront every case with an open mind.  I will fully and fairly analyze the legal arguments that are presented.  I will be open to the considered views of my colleagues on the bench, and I will decide every case based on the record, according the rule of law, without fear or favor, to the best of my ability," said Mr. Roberts.

Judge Roberts' comments concluded a day of opening statements by members of the Judiciary Committee.

Chairman Arlen Specter, a Pennsylvania Republican, used the opportunity to criticize the Supreme Court for overturning laws passed by Congress:

"I am concerned about what I bluntly say is the denigration by the court of congressional authority," said Mr. Specter.

Senators are to begin questioning Judge Roberts Tuesday.  Democrats, including Senator Ted Kennedy of Massachusetts, are particularly interested in knowing the nominee's views on abortion and civil rights issues.

"This committee and the full Senate must determine whether you have demonstrated a commitment to the constitutional principles that have been so vital in advancing fairness, decency and equal opportunity in our society," said Mr. Kennedy.  "We have only one chance to get it right, and a solemn obligation to do so."

Republicans, including Senator John Cornyn of Texas, are warning Judge Roberts about answering some of the Democrats' questions, because that could force the nominee to prejudge cases that may come before the high court.

"You have no obligation to tell us how you would rule on any issue that might come before you if you are confirmed to the Supreme Court," said Mr. Cornyn.

If confirmed, Judge Roberts, 50, who has served as an appeals court judge for the past two years, could play a key role in shaping the direction of the high court for years to come.  Supreme Court justices serve for life.

Democrats acknowledge that they have not found anything in Judge Roberts' record that would derail his nomination.  Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist says he expects the nominee to be confirmed by the full Senate before the high court opens its new session October 3rd. 
 
Judge Roberts initially had been nominated by President Bush to replace retiring Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, but was elevated to chief justice nominee with the death of Chief Justice William Rehnquist earlier this month.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Wide Range of Legal Issues Surface at Roberts Hearings
Funeral Services Held for US Chief Justice
Supreme Court Nominee Generates Interest, Concern and Debate
US Lawmakers, Public Mourn Deceased Chief Justice
Mourners Attend Chief Justice Rehnquist Memorial
 
  Top Story
Soldiers, Family Come Together To Grieve at Fort Hood  Video clip available

  More Stories
Obama Pays Tribute to Fort Hood Shooting Victims   Audio Clip Available  Video clip available
Details Emerge About Alleged Fort Hood Shooter  Audio Clip Available  Video clip available
Washington Area Sniper Executed
Bomb Rocks Northwestern Pakistan
China Ready to Welcome President Obama  Video clip available
US Urges North Korea Not to Escalate Tensions in Yellow Sea
British PM Defends Military Mission in Afghanistan  Audio Clip Available
Lebanon's Unity Government Convenes for First Time
Tropical Storm Ida Downgraded; Moves Inland
Report: Africa's Disappearing Wetlands Produce 'Alarming' Levels of Greenhouse Gas
IEA Urges Action on Climate Change
Somali Pirates Deny Arms Seizure  Audio Clip Available
Cross-Examination Begins in War Crimes Trial of Former Liberian President  Audio Clip Available
US Development of H1N1 Vaccine Hits Snag  Video clip available
Asia to Welcome President Obama  Video clip available
Obama Makes First China Tour as Economic Interdependence Grows  Audio Clip Available  Video clip available
APEC Marks 20 Years, Looks to Future of Regional Trade  Audio Clip Available
Clinton Urges 'Compassion' for Americans Detained in Iran  Audio Clip Available
World War II Museum Expansion Aims at Younger Generations  Audio Clip Available  Video clip available
North Carolina World War II Veterans Honored in Washington  Video clip available