Text Only
Search

 
US Calls Iran 'Test' for Security Council; Russia, China Balk


18 January 2006
Heinlein report (Real Media) - Download 403k - Download (Real) audio clip
Heinlein report (Real Media) - Download 403k - Listen (Real) audio clip

ap us amb un john bolton 210
John Bolton
(AP photo)
The U.S. ambassador to the United Nations says Iran's nuclear program should be a test case for the Security Council. But Chinese and Russian envoys remain reluctant to take up the issue.

As U.S. and European diplomatic pressure on Iran mounted Tuesday, Chinese and Russian diplomats suggested there may still be time for negotiations.

U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations John Bolton maintained the Security Council has clear authority in the Iran uranium enrichment case under the U.N. charter. He called it a classic threat to international peace and security. But, acknowledging the diverse views among Council members, Ambassador Bolton cautioned that there is no guarantee of success.

"There are no guarantees in the Security Council. This will be a test for the Council, and appropriately so, because the Iranian pursuit of nuclear weapons and ballistic missile delivery systems threatens their region and threatens the world as a whole," he said.

But he cautioned that the Council's role should remained secondary, in enforcing the authority of the International Atomic Energy Agency, known as the I.A.E.A.

"That's not to say in any way that the IAEA will be displaced. Quite the contrary. We think Security Council involvement brings the possibility of strengthening the hand of the IAEA in dealing with the Iranian nuclear weapons program," he said.

But while American and European diplomats spoke confidently of a Security Council referral, two powerful Council members urged that diplomacy be given another chance. China's U.N. Ambassador Wang Guangya said taking the issue to the Security Council might have negative consequences.

"To refer this issue to the Security council where the P-5 [permanent five Security Council members] are still divided, I believe that under the current circumstances, when all sides are still talking about the possibility of resuming the negotiations, so talk too much about the Security Council and about sanctions would be counterproductive," he said.

Diplomats noted that the British draft text proposing Security Council referral stops short of recommending sanctions against Iran. Speaking to VOA, Russia's U.N. Ambassador Andrey Denisov called talk of sanctions "inappropriate".

"So how can we speak about sanctions or not sanctions. It's too early. All the instruments should be used in order to try to calm down situation, and to settle the matter. If for example, Iran, maybe it looks like wishful thinking, but if Iran announces that it is keen to resume moratorium, which definitely should be the best solution, then all the talks abut sanctions would be absolutely senseless," he said.

But while Russia shares China's concerns that taking Iran to the Security Council, Moscow has in the past few days moved closer to western views. The U.S. ambassador to the I.A.E.A. Greg Shulte told VOA's Persian service Tuesday that U.S., European, Russian and Chinese envoys have recently discussed gradually increasing diplomatic pressure on Tehran if it fails to suspend its uranium enrichment activities.

Ambassador Shulte said he is "fairly confident" the agency's board will report Iran to the Council at its February second meeting.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
US Envoy 'Fairly Confident' IAEA Will Report Iran to UN Security Council
Israel Says It Will Not Tolerate a Nuclear Iran
Japan Takes Diplomatic Role in Iran Nuclear Issue
Russian Foreign Minister Says Diplomatic Solution to Iranian Nuclear Standoff Still Possible
 
  Top Story
Obama Requests Changes to Afghan Options

  More Stories
Pakistan Seeks Role in US-Afghan Policy
At Least 10 Soldiers Killed in Pakistan Clashes
Obama Honors US Military Veterans  Video clip available
French, German Leaders Commemorate Armistice Day  Audio Clip Available
Obama's Middle East Strategy Stalls
Body of Missing US Soldier Found in Afghanistan
Yemen, US Sign Military Cooperation Deal
Pirates Seize Cargo Ship in Indian Ocean
Clinton: Naval Clash Won't Stop Outreach to North Korea  Audio Clip Available
Japan to Tell Obama It Wants Okinawa Marine Base Closed  Audio Clip Available
APEC Foreign Ministers Discourage Protectionism  Audio Clip Available
Zimbabwe Land Seizures Reportedly Intensify  Audio Clip Available