Text Only
Search

 
US Rejects Burmese Constitution Process as 'Total Sham'


04 September 2007
Gollust report (mp3) - Download 740k audio clip
Listen to Gollust report (mp3) audio clip

The United States Tuesday dismissed as a "total sham" the outline for a new Burmese constitution produced by a national convention assembled by the country's military government. The State Department says the results of the "illegitimate" convention do not represent the will of the Burmese people. VOA's David Gollust reports from the State Department.

Burma's acting Prime Minister Lt. General Thein Sein delivers an opening address at the National Convention in Nyaunghnapin, 18 Jul 2007
Burma's acting Prime Minister Lt. General Thein Sein delivers an opening address at the National Convention in Nyaunghnapin, 18 Jul 2007
The United States has long been critical of the constitution-writing exercise in Burma, because it excluded principal opposition groups and ethnic minorities.

It is now dismissing the results of the process - a set of guidelines for a new constitution, as a sham document without any political legitimacy.

The Burmese military leadership announced Tuesday that after 14 years of on-and-off work, the convention had produced a set of charter guidelines that will eventually lead to national elections.

Despite the junta's depiction of the guidelines as part of a democratic "road map," domestic and international critics immediately condemned the package, saying its provisions would insure that the military remains the dominant force in the country.

Tom Casey
Tom Casey
At a news briefing, State Department Deputy Spokesman Tom Casey said for the process to have had any legitimacy, it would have had to have included opposition factions, notably Aung San Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy.

"I think our simplest response to it is we view it as a total sham," said Casey. "The delegates to this convention were hand-picked by the regime. They haven't been allowed to engage in any open debate, and of course they also excluded the National League for Democracy, which is Burma's largest political party."

"It's also somewhat ironic that the conclusions of this supposed open political process coincide with a crackdown on citizens for peacefully protesting, and trying to exercise their freedom of expression," he continued.

Aung San Suu Kyi's party won national elections in a landslide in 1990 but was barred by the military from taking power. The 1991 Nobel Peace laureate has been under various forms of detention most of the time since then, including house arrest since May of 2003.

News accounts say the guidelines would give the military continued control of key ministries and unelected blocks of seats in legislative bodies, while limiting the rights of political parties with provisions tailored to exclude Aung San Suu Kyi and her party.

Spokesman Casey said it is hard to see how the work of the constitutional convention is salvageable.

A written statement here reaffirmed the U.S. call for "genuine, inclusive dialogue" between the junta and opposition factions, leading to a civilian, democratic government that respects human rights.

Min Ko Naing (l) and other members of the 88 Generation Students group march through Rangoon to protest over fuel price hikes, 19 Aug 2007
Min Ko Naing (l) and other members of the 88 Generation Students group march through Rangoon to protest over fuel price hikes, 19 Aug 2007
The U.S. statement also called on the junta, which has responded harshly in recent days to public protests over fuel price increases, to halt the arrest and harassment of non-violent activists, release all political prisoners, end attacks on civilians in ethnic minority areas and lift curbs on humanitarian aid groups.

Casey said he expects the Burmese human rights issue to be revisited by the U.N. Security Council in the coming weeks. A U.S.-sponsored resolution condemning Burma won majority support in the council last January but was vetoed by vetoes by Russia and China.

 

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Burma Ends 14-Year Process on Drafting New Constitution
UN Investigator Asks Burma to Release Protesters
US Condemns Burma's 'Heavy-Handed' Crackdown on Dissent
 
  Top Story
Berlin Wall Celebration Marked by Joy and Caution  Audio Clip Available

  More Stories
Officials Warn of Possible Collapse of Palestinian Authority
Hariri Names New Lebanese Government After Five Week Vacuum  Audio Clip Available
US Had Previously Monitored Fort Hood Shooting Suspect
NATO: 130 Militants Killed in Afghanistan
US, Germany Press Afghan President on Reform  Audio Clip Available
Clinton Urges 'Compassion' for Americans Detained in Iran  Audio Clip Available
Iran Charges 3 US Detainees with Espionage
Iraq Electoral Official Says Vote Will Happen On Time   Audio Clip Available
Afghans React To Possible US Troop Surge  Audio Clip Available
Suicide Bomber Kills 3 in Northwestern Pakistan
China Executes Nine Ethnic Uighurs in July Unrest
APEC Economies Report Improved Trade Finance, Discuss Free Trade  Audio Clip Available
Scientists Report Abnormal Sea Level Rises Off Western Australia  Audio Clip Available
Tropical Storm Ida Aims For US Gulf Coast;  State of Emergency in Effect
Obama Makes First China Tour as Economic Interdependence Grows  Video clip available