Text Only
Search

 
India's Low-Key Response to Burma Protests Driven By Security Concerns


01 October 2007
Pasricha report (mp3) - Download 576k audio clip
Listen to Pasricha report (mp3) audio clip

India's guarded response to the crackdown on pro-democracy protesters in neighboring Burma has drawn criticism from those who want the world's largest democracy to speak more loudly against the Burmese military junta. But, as Anjana Pasricha reports from New Delhi, analysts say India is walking a diplomatic tightrope to protect its own strategic interests in the region.

While much of the world has adopted a tough posture to the recent violent crackdown on pro-democracy protesters in Burma, India's response was brief and carefully worded.

In a statement, Foreign Minister Pranab Mukherjee expressed hope that all sides will resolve their issues peacefully through dialogue, and "all sections of people will be included in a broad-based process of national reconciliation and political reform."

The statement disappointed human rights groups and many in Western countries who want India to demonstrate regional leadership and nudge the military junta toward real political reform.

"India is expected, as the largest democratic country, to issue a harsher statement," said Suhas Chakma, the director of the Asian Center for Human Rights, based in New Delhi. "It is very unfortunate."

But foreign policy analysts are not surprised by India's low-key response. They say it is in line with New Delhi's policy of engaging Burma's military junta to meet its own strategic interests.

The reversal of India's strong support for Burma's democracy movement and its leader Aung San Suu Kyi began in the mid 1990's. It was triggered by three factors: New Delhi wanted the military junta to act against rebels who were using bases in Burma to wage insurgencies in India's northeast. India also wanted to counter China's growing influence in the region and secure a stake in Burma's rich energy resources.

India's decision to do business with the military junta culminated in 2004, when New Delhi hosted a visit by Burma's military leader, Than Shwe.

Analysts say India's policy, like that of many other countries, is driven by realpolitik. International relations expert former Major General Ashok Mehta says Western countries also work with military regimes in the pursuit of larger security interests, such as the war against terrorism.

"You take the case of the United States, I am only giving one example. [The] United States has strategic interests in areas bordering Pakistan, in Afghanistan, and therefore, while it talks about restoration or revival of democracy and human rights, there is very little it does to ensure that happens there," he said.

India's naval and air force chiefs have visited Burma in the past year as New Delhi has steadily deepened its military cooperation with its neighbor.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
UN Security Council Urges Restraint Against Burmese Protesters
ASEAN Under Pressure to Press Burma Against Violence
China Likely Advising Burmese Leaders to Show Restraint
 
  Top Story
Afghanistan Fighting Kills 2 US Soldiers, 30 Militants

  More Stories
Biden Celebrates US Independence Day with Troops in Iraq
New US Offensive in Southern Afghanistan Puts Pakistani Military on Alert
North Korea Test Fires Short Range Missiles  Audio Clip Available
Top Iran Hardline Paper Calls for Mousavi Treason Trial  Audio Clip Available
US Republicans Call for Stronger Position on Iran
UN Chief Rebukes Burma's Leaders
Americans Gear Up for July 4 Holiday
OAS to Vote on Suspending Honduras
Palin Resigning as Alaska Governor
Obama Prepares for Russia Summit, G8, Africa Visit  Audio Clip Available
Putin: US-Russia Ties Will Improve if US Halts Missile Defense Plans
Australia's Aborigines at Risk as Swine Flu Outbreak Escalates  Audio Clip Available
Michael Jackson Memorial Planned for Fans, Family Tuesday