Text Only
Search

 
Venezuela Defends Chavez After Spat With Spanish King


11 November 2007
Bowman report - Download MP3 (641k) audio clip
Listen to Bowman report audio clip

Venezuelan officials are blasting Spain's king after the monarch told President Hugo Chavez to "shut up" at the close of the Ibero-American summit in Santiago, Chile. VOA's Michael Bowman reports from Washington, the verbal spat stole the spotlight from the gathering of leaders from Latin America, Spain and Portugal.

Spain's Prime Minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero (l) watches as King Juan Carlos addresses Hugo Chavez, 10 Nov 2007
Spain's Prime Minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero (l) watches as King Juan Carlos addresses Hugo Chavez, 10 Nov 2007
The yearly Ibero-American summit is known for generating often-bland plenary statements, not heated verbal salvos between participants. Saturday, a speech by President Chavez in which he labeled former Spanish Prime Minister Jose Maria Aznar a "fascist" later prompted blunt words from an irate King Juan Carlos of Spain.

The king said, "Why do you not shut up?"

In Caracas Sunday, Vice President Jorge Rodriguez suggested the Spanish monarch may have forgotten that Latin America achieved its independence from Spain long ago, and said the king's words were "unacceptable".

Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez, left, talks to Spain's PM Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, unseen, during the last working session of the XVII Iberoamerican Summit in Santiago, Chile, 10 Nov. 2007
Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez, left, talks to Spain's PM Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, unseen, during the last working session of the XVII Iberoamerican Summit in Santiago, Chile, 10 Nov. 2007
He said, "Mr. Juan Carlos can treat his subjects in that fashion if they permit him to do so. But we Venezuelans are a free and sovereign people constructing our own future. No one can speak vulgar words to deny Venezuela's chief of state the right to speak. Nothing and no one will ever silence him [Chavez]."

President Chavez has long criticized former Prime Minister Aznar for joining with the United States in the 2003 invasion of Iraq that toppled Saddam Hussein. The current Spanish prime minister, Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, also opposed Spain's participation in the Iraq campaign. But, speaking at the summit, he reminded Mr. Chavez that his predecessor was legitimately elected by the people of Spain -- and deserved to be spoken of with respect.

He said, "President Hugo Chavez, I believe there is a principle in dialogue and that is, to respect and to be respected, we must try not to disregard others. We can disagree entirely with someone's ideas or behavior without insulting them."

Mr. Chavez repeatedly tried to interrupt the Spanish leader, but his microphone was turned off. It was at that point that King Juan Carlos, seated a few meters away, leaned forward and uttered his now-famous exhortation to the Venezuelan leader.

The sharp words made headlines and have provoked commentary throughout the Spanish-speaking world and beyond. In a written statement published by Cuban state media, President Fidel Castro - who did not attend the summit - backed what he called President Chavez' "devastating criticisms" of Europe.

For his part, the Venezuelan leader has downplayed the controversy. Speaking with reporters, Mr. Chavez said he did not hear King Juan Carlos' outburst at the time. Mr. Chavez added that he never meant for his choice of words to offend anybody at the summit, but that he stood by those words nonetheless.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Spanish King Tells Venezuela's Chavez to 'Shut Up'
Four Venezuelan Police Officers Shot in Student Protest
 
  Top Story
US House Debates Health Care Reform Measure

  More Stories
G20: Financial Stimulus Still Needed to Stabilize Economic Recovery
Obama Praises Those Who Ended Fort Hood Rampage
Iran Lawmakers Say Tehran Will Reject UN-Backed Nuclear Deal
Afghanistan: NATO Strike Kills 7 Afghan Security Members  Audio Clip Available
Afghanistan Rejects UN Criticism of Karzai
China's Wen Promises Greater Cooperation With Arab Nations  Audio Clip Available
Pakistan Army: 12 Militants Killed in Recent Fighting
Army Sends Counselors to Ft. Hood, as Investigation Continues  Video clip available
Iraqi Lawmakers Fail to Vote on Election Law
Medvedev: Not All Hopes Realized After Berlin Wall Fell
ICC Prosecutor Promises Speed in Kenya Proceedings  Audio Clip Available
US Disappointed at Breakdown in Honduras Political Talks
Berlin Prepares for Celebrations 20 Years After Fall of Wall  Video clip available
Harnessing Waste Produces Gas for Cooking in Kenya  Video clip available