Text Only
Search

 
Analysts Say Hopes for Pakistan Political Truce Slim


14 November 2007
Thomas report - Download MP3 (856k) audio clip
Listen to Thomas report audio clip

U.S. Deputy Secretary of State John Negroponte is heading to Pakistan late this week to meet with President Pervez Musharraf.  The U.S. is hoping to cool the rising political temperature brought on by General Musharraf's imposition of a state of emergency.  But as VOA correspondent Gary Thomas reports, General Musharraf has already rejected U.S. calls to lift emergency rule.

Analysts say hopes that U.S. intercession can change the deteriorating political situation are dim, and become dimmer with the passage of time as both General Musharraf and his chief rival, Benazir Bhutto, harden their positions.

Pakistani President Gen. Pervez Musharraf wipes sweat from his neck as he addresses the international media in Islamabad, Pakistan Sunday, 11 Nov. 2007
Pakistani President Gen. Pervez Musharraf wipes sweat from his neck as he addresses the international media in Islamabad, Pakistan Sunday, 11 Nov. 2007
Robert Grenier, former CIA station chief in Islamabad, says General Musharraf would have to repudiate all that he has done since imposing emergency rule earlier this month, and that such a move is not likely.

"The state of emergency would have to be lifted, the constitution would have to be put back in force, the Supreme Court justices would have to be reinstated," he explained.  "Essentially, at this point, to have any hope of going forward where General Musharraf would have a continuing role, he would have to completely undo everything that he has done to date.  And I don't see any sign that he's going to do that."

General Musharraf says parliamentary elections will be held by January 9.  But U.S. officials say free and fair elections cannot be held with emergency rule in place.

Benazir Bhutto in Lahore, Pakistan<br />12 Nov 2007
Benazir Bhutto in Lahore, Pakistan
12 Nov 2007
Opposition leader and former prime minister Benazir Bhutto returned home from self-imposed exile last month under the outlines of a broad, still-imprecise power-sharing arrangement, partially brokered by the United States, between her and President Musharraf.

But she has been prevented from leaving her house to lead marches or rallies.  She now says she cannot work with General Musharraf and has called for his resignation.  Most analysts say that position now makes the chances of a bringing the two sides together virtually nil.

The United States has viewed General Musharraf as an "indispensable" ally in the battle against terrorism.  Larry Goodson, a professor in security studies at the U.S. Army War College, says that has caused the United States to ignore General Musharraf's shortcomings.

"I think the problem we have in Washington is that we have always settled for the short-term strategic partnership rather than the long-term 'let's build a better Pakistan that is able to be a more stable, functioning place in the world,'" he said.  "And I suspect that in the midst of a crisis like this we will hold our noses, nudge him on the margins while convincing ourselves that we're nudging him in important ways and continue to tell ourselves that he's an important ally in the war on terror and we just have to deal with it."

Pakistani journalists chant slogans at a protest against the government media crackdown, 10 Nov 07
Pakistani journalists chant slogans at a protest against the government media crackdown, 10 Nov 07
But Teresita Schaffer, former deputy assistant secretary of state for South Asia, says there are powerful voices in the U.S. government who want to hang on to General Musharraf.  But, she adds, there is also a growing realization in other quarters that General Musharraf's actions have made him a liability for the United States.

"I think his moment has passed," she explained.  "And I suppose it's possible in theory that he could put together enough power simply by repression to stay on top, although that's becoming increasingly problematic, but what would that be worth to the United States?"

The key question, analysts say, is if the top ranks of the Pakistan Army feel that their military chief and president has become an embarrassment to them.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
White House Repeats Calls For Pakistan's Musharraf to Lift Emergency Rule
Pakistani Police Arrest Former Cricket Star, Opposition Leader, Imran Khan
Pakistani Opposition Considers Alternatives After Protests Thwarted
 
  Top Story
US House Nears Vote on Health Care Reform Measure

  More Stories
Iran Lawmakers Say Tehran Will Reject UN-Backed Nuclear Deal
G20: Financial Stimulus Still Needed to Stabilize Economic Recovery
Afghanistan: NATO Strike Kills 7 Afghan Security Members  Audio Clip Available
Israelis Rally for Peace on Rabin Anniversary
Obama Praises Those Who Ended Fort Hood Rampage
Afghanistan Rejects UN Criticism of Karzai
Navy Ship Honoring 9/11 Victims is Commissioned Into Fleet
China's Wen Promises Greater Cooperation With Arab Nations  Audio Clip Available
Pakistan Army: 12 Militants Killed in Recent Fighting
Iraqi Parliament Fails Again to Approve New Electoral Law
Medvedev: Not All Hopes Realized After Berlin Wall Fell
US Disappointed at Breakdown in Honduras Political Talks
Berlin Prepares for Celebrations 20 Years After Fall of Wall  Video clip available
Harnessing Waste Produces Gas for Cooking in Kenya  Video clip available