Text Only
Search

Tobacco Control Programs Reduce Health-Care Costs


02 September 2008
Lapidus report - Download (MP3) audio clip
Lapidus report - Listen (MP3) audio clip

Quitting smoking reduces your risk of heart attack, cancer and other tobacco-related diseases, and it also has a benefit for your community – lower health care costs. Faith Lapidus explains.

This poster from the California Tobacco Control Program portrays cigarette companies as interested only in money
This poster from the California Tobacco Control Program portrays cigarette companies as interested only in money
In 1988, California voters approved spending tax dollars from an increased cigarette tax on an anti-smoking effort. The state's Tobacco Control Program was innovative for its time, according to Stan Glantz, who directs the Center for Tobacco Control Research and Education at the University of California, San Francisco.

"It took a very strong approach directed around social norm change," he explains, rather than simply telling people not to smoke because it was bad, or telling kids they shouldn't start smoking. "It had very, very aggressive media, to create an environment to discourage smoking and help smokers quit. It had a strong emphasis on second-hand smoke and public policy interventions, particularly creating smoke-free environments, smoke-free workplaces, smoke-free public places." It also included a "quit line," which offered advice for callers who wanted to quit smoking.

Glantz and his colleagues used statistical analysis to assess the program's performance during its first 15 years. They compared state spending on the control program between 1989 and 2004 to the decline in the smoking population, and compared that decline to what happened to personal health care costs – spending by individuals, insurance companies and the government. Then, using states that did not have tobacco control programs as the control group, Glantz says they compared what they estimated California's health care costs would have been had the program not been there, and compared that figure to what they actually were.

Butt-filled ashtray
Butt-filled ashtray
"And what you find is if you had not had the California Tobacco Control Program, a lot more cigarettes would have been smoked and health care costs would have been higher." Seven-point-three percent higher, to be exact.

Glantz calls that effect "gigantic." A program that cost less than $2-billion over 15 years saved $86-billion in health care expenditures. And those costs began to drop in the program's first year.

Glantz notes that similar tobacco control programs will soon become more common around the world because of the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control. "[It] is the first global public health treaty, it's sort of like the Kyoto [Climate Change] Accords for tobacco," he explains. The framework has been ratified by 157 countries so far. "One of articles in there commits the ratifying countries to develop and implement large-scale tobacco control programs."

Stan Glantz says California's experience has shown that you can lower health care costs by reducing tobacco-induced disease, and that successful health care reform requires a large-scale tobacco control effort.

His paper is published in the August issue of PLoS Medicine, an open-access on-line journal.

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Top Story
Obama, World Leaders Honor Veterans on Anniversary of End WWI

  More Stories
French, German Leaders Commemorate Armistice Day  Audio Clip Available
Body of Missing US Soldier Found in Afghanistan
APEC Foreign Ministers Discourage Protectionism  Audio Clip Available
Clinton Urges Asian Pressure on Burma for Free Elections  Audio Clip Available
Clinton: Naval Clash Won't Stop Outreach to North Korea  Audio Clip Available
South Korean Military on High Alert After Naval Clash
UN Prosecutors Seek to Limit Taylor's Contact With Lawyers During Cross Examination  Audio Clip Available
Abbas Renews Call for Settlement Halt
Japan to Tell Obama It Wants Okinawa Marine Base Closed  Audio Clip Available
Egyptian Activist Nour Presses For More Rights in Political Process  Audio Clip Available
Australian PM Flies to India to Soothe Diplomatic Tensions
Cambodia Rejects Thai Request to Extradite Former Leader  Audio Clip Available
World War II Museum Expansion Aims at Younger Generations  Audio Clip Available  Video clip available
  Related Links
Full article
Video by Stan Glantz and Jim Lightwood