Text Only
Search

New Evidence Sparks US Review of its Claims on Afghan Attack


08 September 2008
Pessin report - Download (MP3) audio clip
Pessin report - Listen (MP3) audio clip

After receiving new evidence in recent days, the U.S. military is launching a higher level investigation of its air strike in Afghanistan two weeks ago, in which dozens of people were killed.  The initial U.S. investigation said the strike had killed at least 30 militants and between five and seven civilians.  That disputed reports by Afghan and U.N. investigators, who said more then 90 civilians had been killed, many of them children.  VOA's Al Pessin reports from the Pentagon.

A boy carries his belongings next to the rubble of his home which was destroyed in a US airstrike in the village of Azizabad in Shindand district of Herat province, Afghanistan, 23 Aug 2008
A boy carries his belongings next to the rubble of his home which was destroyed in a US airstrike in the village of Azizabad in Shindand district of Herat province, Afghanistan, 23 Aug 2008
The official statement from the coalition command in Afghanistan said the investigating officer based his conclusions on statements from 30 people, including air crews and U.S. and Afghan ground forces.  The statement, issued a week ago, said troops had also collected weapons, explosives and various types of information at the scene in the village of Azizabad, had video and photographs of the attack site, and had looked at burial grounds and gotten reports from local clinics and hospitals.

But the statement also says U.S. and Afghan authorities were kept out of the village the day after the attack, and the investigator was not given access to any information collected by "other organizations," an apparent reference to the U.N. and Afghan government investigations.

But Pentagon Spokesman Bryan Whitman says the top U.S. and NATO commander in Afghanistan, General David McKiernan, has now been presented with additional evidence.

Pentagon spokesman Brian Whitman (file photo)
Pentagon spokesman Brian Whitman (file photo)
"There was some additional evidence, there was some imagery that came to his attention, that gave him reason to want to take a look at the investigation that we have done on this," said Bryan Whitman.

Whitman would not be specific, but reports from Kabul say U.N. officials showed General McKiernan a video shot with a mobile phone showing dozens of bodies in Azizabad, many of which appeared to be civilians rather than fighters.

"While we attempt to do very thorough and comprehensive investigations, we also try to do them in an expeditious fashion, particularly in this case because it had a lot of interest, and there were some conflicting reports," he said. "And then the investigating officer made some determinations.  But in light of, over the weekend, General McKiernan receiving some new evidence, some imagery evidence, he made the decision, based on this new evidence, that he wanted a review of the initial investigation."

The military says a combined U.S. and Afghan force entered Azizabad on August 22 and took heavy fire from militants in the village.  The initial investigation found the troops were "justified" and acted within "existing rules of engagement" in returning fire and calling in the air strike that resulted in the dispute over casualties.  The investigator concluded that a Taliban commander known as Mullah Sadiq was among those killed.

The U.S. military regularly takes longer than other organizations to investigate incidents involving allegations of civilian casualties, saying it is more concerned about its reports being accurate than fast.  Whitman says General McKiernan wants to find out why in this case, after a 10-day investigation, the U.S. military may have gotten it wrong.

"There is some evidence that suggests that the evidence that the United States military used in the conduct of its investigation may not have been complete," said Whitman. "But we will see."

U.S. Central Command, which has authority over all U.S. military activity in the Middle East and Central Asia, is expected to dispatch a general from its headquarters in Florida to handle the new investigation.  Whitman says "nothing has resulted" from a U.S. offer to conduct a joint investigation with Afghan officials.   

 

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Suspected US Missile Strike Hits Taliban Commander's House
US Military to Re-Investigate Afghan Civilian Deaths
Twin Blasts Hit Police HQ in Kandahar
 
  Top Story
Obama: Iraq Election Law an "Important Milestone"  Audio Clip Available

  More Stories
Iraqi Parliament Approves New Electoral Law After Raucous Debate  Audio Clip Available
US Army Chief of Staff: More Troops Needed in Afghanistan
Market Bomber Kills 13 in Northwest Pakistan
Clinton Urges Europeans to Bring Down "Walls" of Terrorism, Oppression  Audio Clip Available
Berlin to Mark the 20th Anniversary of the Fall of the Berlin Wall  Audio Clip Available  Video clip available
Hurricane Ida Heads Toward Gulf of Mexico, Floods Kill 91 in El Salvador
Russia-Iran Relations Balancing on Nuclear Issue
Motive Sought for Texas Mass Shooting
Dalai Lama Rejects Chinese Criticism of Monastery Visit  Audio Clip Available
China's Premier Pledges $10 billion in Loans to Africa  Audio Clip Available
Netanyahu Heads to US Amid Crisis in Peace Process  Audio Clip Available
Japan Pledges More Aid to Burma if Political Prisoners are Released
WFP Making Inroads on Alleviating Hunger  Audio Clip Available
Deposed Madagascar President says He Will Work With Rival Who Ousted Him  Audio Clip Available
US Health Care Debate Continues on Partisan Lines