Text Only
Search

US Says Georgia Erred in August Attack in South Ossetia


07 November 2008
Gollust report - Download (MP3) audio clip
Gollust report - Listen (MP3) audio clip

The U.S. State Department said Friday the Georgian attack in South Ossetia last August was a mistake, but that it did not justify Russia's large-scale intervention. The comments follow a critical newspaper assessment of the Tbilisi government's role in the crisis. VOA's David Gollust reports from the State Department.

Russian NTV channel television grab shows Georgian troops ride in tanks during conflict with separatist South Ossetian troops at an unnamed location, 08 Aug 2008
Russian NTV channel television grab shows Georgian troops ride in tanks during conflict with separatist South Ossetian troops at an unnamed location, 08 Aug 2008
In its most specific comments on the subject to date, the State Department says Georgian leaders made a mistake when they attacked the capital of breakaway South Ossetia, Tskhinvali, in August.

But officials here say overall culpability for the war may never be known, and the focus now should be on getting Georgia, and especially Russia, to heed ceasefire obligations, and help return the region to stability.

The comments follow a New York Times report Friday, which quoted independent military observers as saying Georgian forces indiscriminately shelled Tskhinvali in the early-morning attack August 7, endangering civilians, OSCE monitors and Russian peacekeepers.

The newspaper said the monitors' account calls into question Georgia's assertion that the attack was precisely aimed at military targets, and defensive following South Ossetian provocations and a Russian military buildup.

The Tskhinvali attack was followed by large-scale intervention by Russian forces, who routed Georgia troops and ended up holding large sections of Georgian territory beyond the disputed areas of South Ossetia and Abkhazia.

At a news briefing, State Department Deputy Spokesman Robert Wood said the Georgia attack was mistaken, but did not justify the Russian response.

He said the United States in the run-up to the war had urged both Georgia and Russia not to provoke, or be provoked, by the other side. He said the U.S. stress now is not assigning blame, but returning stability to the region.

"I think we need to get away from looking at who did what first, because, as I said, I don't think we'll ever really get to the bottom of that," said Wood. "The important thing is for us to move forward, and that's what we're trying to do, in terms of trying to reconstruct Georgia, bring about stability to the general region. And that's what we are going to focus on."

A senior official here said the Bush administration is disinclined to fix blame for the war, saying it could inflame matters and that it doesn't help, as he put it, to go back and re-fight history.

The United States has credited Moscow with adhering to cease-fire commitments to remove troops and checkpoints from Georgian territory beyond the South Ossetia and Abkhazia enclaves, though officials say Russia does not appear to have reduced troop levels in the two areas to pre-conflict numbers.

At a donors' conference for Georgia two weeks ago, the United States pledged $1 billion to support the country's economic recovery. The Brussels conference overall raised more than $4 billion in loans and grants for the Tbilisi government.

 

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Georgia Crisis Revealed the West’s Limited Leverage With Russia
Russia: No EU Monitors in Georgian Breakaway Territories
Donors Pledge More than $4 Billion to Georgia Recovery
 
  Top Story
Abbas Aides: Palestinian Leader Will Not Seek Re-Election

  More Stories
Israel Accuses Iran of War Crimes Over Arms-Laden Ship
UN Relocates Staff in Afghanistan Over Security Concerns
ICC Prosecutor to Request Probe Into Kenya's Post-Election Violence
Suspected US Drone Attack Kills 2 in Pakistan
Minority Communities Say Burma Development Projects Lead to Abuses, Environmental Damage  Audio Clip Available
US Diplomats Urge Burma's Military to Talk With Opposition, Ethnic Groups  Audio Clip Available
China Rejects US Pressure to Agree to Carbon Emissions Cuts  Audio Clip Available
US Billionaire Bets Big on US Economy  Video clip available
Governments See Dollars in Re-Grown Forests  Audio Clip Available
Stage Set for Historic US Health Care Debate  Audio Clip Available
Researchers Say Elderly Not Necessarily Immune From Severe H1N1 Flu  Video clip available
New York Yankees Win Major League Baseball's Coveted Championship Title  Audio Clip Available
Sierra Leonean-American Football Star Launches Global Health Center