VOANews.com

 
Live Streams:  Latest Newscast |  Africa Live |  Global Live
News in 45 Languages
Support for Female Circumcision Declining in Egypt


09 July 2009

The history of female circumcision, also called female genital cutting or mutilation, is unclear. Some say it's a religious requirement for Islamic women, while others point out that the practice pre-dates the spread of Islam. The practice is controversial in many countries. Westerners decry the practice, yet, it persists in many African and Islamic countries because of strong cultural support.

Now, new research finds the practice is losing support in one large country - Egypt. In that country, historical evidence indicates that female cutting has been done since the time of the pharaohs. Traditionally, it's been seen as a requirement to make girls marriageable.

But the current government in Egypt banned female circumcision in the 1990s and strengthened the restriction in 2007 after a high-profile case where a 12-year-old girl died after the ritual.

However, female circumcision is still widespread, says Ann Way, a researcher with the organization Measure DHS, which has been collecting information on the practice since 1995.

"The prevalence of circumcision among ever-married women at that point was over 90 percent," Way says.

Measure DHS helps countries calculate vital statistics by doing large surveys, often repeated over the course of years. Way and her colleagues asked women about female circumcision again in 2000, and most recently, last year. She says they are starting to see a reduction in the number of young women who have been circumcised.

"We have seen the rates drop from over 90 [percent] in older women, women aged 25 and older, to just around 80 percent in the age group 15 to 19," she says.

Influential leaders raising questions

The government ban, along with the well-publicized deaths, led some people - most importantly women and religious leaders - to start questioning the practice.

"I think the government and, you know, a number of other organizations have clearly been supporting campaigns which have been directed towards changing people's support for circumcision," Way says.

"You know, at the time of our first survey in 1995, where we looked at the percentage supporting female circumcision, wanting the practice to continue, about eight in 10 ever-married women at that point wanted the practice to continue. In the most recent survey it was only about six in 10 women."

Interestingly, fewer wealthy girls and women currently have the practice performed on them. Only about a third of girls in the wealthiest 20 percent of Egypt's population will be circumcised by the time they're 18. In contrast, in the poorest 20 percent, about three-quarters of the girls will end up circumcised.

Way says attitudes and practices change slowly. She says even if fewer girls are circumcised, it will take time for the total number of adult women who have been circumcised to drop.

Her data is published on the Measure DHS Web site.

 



Comments:

1. FGM and Islam

The Quran is the only Divine Book that forbids FGM and considers it as the deed of the devil. To see a video response to FGM in Islam, please go to youtube channel fitnafitan5 video clip 31/49, go to the end of the 31/49 clip and continou to video clip 32/49.I wonder if the Moslims are going to understand the Quran and live as Moslims?
Submitted by: Saad Noah ()
07-11-2009 - 03:35:47

2. Cultural problem more than religious

Female circumcision is a pre islamic practice. It would come from pharaonic time and has spread all over Africa. It is not an islamic practice, egypt is the only arabic country that has to deal with this tradition. Most of egyptian christian women are also mutilated. Christian coptics represent around 10% of the population in egypt. The higher islamic authority in Cairo, al Azhar, has condemned this practice many times as non islamic. So, one could't say in any case "it's a religious requirement for Islamic women". It would be a nonsense. The problem is definitly cultural and not religious. A lot of egyptians thinks that a non circumcized woman will become a sex addict, therefore a prostitute.
Submitted by: Mariette Bacha (France)
07-10-2009 - 11:32:03

3. FGM Declines in Egypt

To clarify: FGM does predate Islam. It appears to have originated in the Nile littoral, and it has been known since pharaonic times. However, the spread is FGM over Africa was accomplished through the Arab slave trade (ensuring slave virginity with infibulation), and also spread (and is sustained) by Shafi'i Sunni Islam. FGM (and MGM) are mandatory in Shafi'i Sunni Islam. Attempts to exonerate Islam on the fact that Islam "didn't start it" miss the point: Mandatory is mandatory, and ever time dissident tribal and Muslim women try to resist, fatawa admonishing them to continue proliferate like dust storms in the desert in August. And if you think Egypt is really on the right track, why is it that Egyptian delegates to the UN Human Rights Commission screamed bloody murder when someone brought up FGM as a human rights issue? Armed with the Islamic majority in the Council, Egypt and Pakistan succeeded in having the UNHRC -- the world's most necessary and critical defender of human ri
Submitted by: Morgaan Sinclair (United States)
07-10-2009 - 03:27:42

Download Hoban report
Download  (MP3)
Listen to This Report Hoban report
Listen (MP3)
E-mail This Article E-mail This Article
Print This Article Print Version
  Top Story
Market Bomber Kills 13 in Northwest Pakistan

  More Stories
17 Rebels Killed in Afghan Battle
Motive Sought for Texas Mass Shooting
Dalai Lama Rejects Chinese Criticism of Monastery Visit  Audio Clip Available
China's Premier Pledges $10 billion in Loans to Africa  Audio Clip Available
APEC Leaders to Focus on Creating Economic Growth at Singapore Meeting  Audio Clip Available
India's PM Wants Rich Nations to Subsidize Cost for Poorer Countries  Audio Clip Available
Netanyahu Heads to US Amid Crisis in Peace Process  Audio Clip Available
Japan Pledges More Aid to Burma if Political Prisoners are Released
WFP Making Inroads on Alleviating Hunger  Audio Clip Available
US House Approves Health Care Reform Measure  Audio Clip Available
  Related Links
Female Circumcision chapter of 2005 Egypt Demographic and Health Survey
Measure DHS 2008 Survey