VOANews.com

 
Live Streams:  Latest Newscast |  Africa Live |  Global Live
News in 45 Languages
Report: Bush Administration Surveillance Program Legally Questionable

11 July 2009

President George W. Bush makes statement on automaker bailout plan at the White House, 19 Dec 2008
President George W. Bush (File photo)
A review by top U.S. government investigators says a secret surveillance program approved by President George W. Bush after the September 11 terror attacks got too little legal review when it started.

The program included wiretaps without court approval and some unprecedented intelligence collection efforts.  News accounts say it is not clear how effective the highly controversial program was in producing useful intelligence.

The report was published Friday by five inspectors general of agencies with intelligence responsibilities: the Defense and Justice Departments, along with the Central Intelligence Agency, the National Security Agency and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence.

The report concludes information gathered by the secret program played a limited role in the FBI's (Federal Bureau of Investigation) overall counterterrorism efforts.  The report also says very few CIA (Central Intelligence Agency) analysts knew about the program and could not fully use it in their counterterrorism work.

It also questions the legal advice used by Mr. Bush to set up the program.

A Justice Department official, John Yoo, wrote a series of memos in support of the program.  News accounts of the report say those memos ignored laws restricting the government's authority to conduct electronic surveillance during wartime.

Yoo refused to be interviewed by the inspectors general, as did other Bush administration officials, including former CIA director George Tenet, former White House chief of staff Andrew Card, and former attorney general John Ashcroft.  The inspectors general did manage to speak to about 200 people inside and out of government for the investigation.

Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Patrick Leahy is calling for a nonpartisan inquiry into the government's information-gathering programs.

Some information for this report was provided by AP.




E-mail This Article E-mail This Article
Print This Article Print Version
  Related Stories
Democrats, Republicans in New Dispute Over CIA
US Congress Debates Detainee Policy, Military Commissions
Some Guantanamo Bay Detainees May Be Held Indefinitely
 
  Top Story
Iranian Opposition Supporters Return to Streets  Audio Clip Available

  More Stories
UN Takes Up Report on Israeli Palestinian War Crimes  Audio Clip Available
US Calls on Karzai to Fight Corruption  Audio Clip Available
Stage Set for Historic US Health Care Debate  Audio Clip Available
US Senate Extends Homebuyers Tax Credit, Unemployment Aid
Clinton Tries to Reassure Arab Leaders on Israeli Settlements
British Leader Vows Afghan Mission Unchanged  Audio Clip Available
Afghanistan's Abdullah Says Karzai Re-election Lacks Legitimacy
Election Results Could Impact Obama, Democrats  Video clip available
US Envoy Urges Burma to Make Concrete Steps Toward Democracy
Italian Judge Convicts 23 in CIA Kidnap Case
Israel Seizes Ship Loaded With Weapons  Audio Clip Available
Pakistan Army: Troops Reach Key Taliban Strongholds
Researchers Say Elderly Not Necessarily Immune From Severe H1N1 Flu  Video clip available
Indonesia Debates Benefits, Risks of Carbon-Trading Plans
Africa Boycott Steers UN Climate Talks  Audio Clip Available
ICC Prosecutor Faces Uphill Challenges in Kenya Case