VOANews.com

Voice of America - Khmer

19 November 2009 

Today at VOA:

News in 45 Languages
Duch’s Case Could Hold Valuable Lessons


11 November 2009

Cambodia’s laboring justice system may be able to learn from the recent trial of Kaing Kek Iev under the Khmer Rouge tribunal, an added benefit to the UN-backed court, experts say.

Kaing Kek Iev, the former Khmer Rouge prison chief better known as Duch, has undergone trial on charges of crimes against humanity, war crimes, torture and murder. He is awaiting final statements from the Trial Chamber, following six months of questioning and witness testimony.

Cambodian media have faithfully covered the proceedings, and decisions from the three chambers of the court have been posted on the court’s Web site. All of that could have a positive effect on Cambodia’s regular courts, as well as helping the country overcome its collective trauma.

“This court has given equal rights to both victims and the accused to have Khmer and foreign lawyers, and they have been given enough time for questions and answers,” Kek Galabru, founder of the prominent rights group Lichado, told VOA Khmer recently. “I see that their procedure is up to international standards, and I hope that from today onward Cambodia’s courts can follow the examples set by the Khmer Rouge tribunal.”

Long Panhavuth, a tribunal monitor for the Open Society Justice Initiative, said, “Duch’s trial will be a victory.”

The trial demonstrated a “criminal case procedure that does not exist in our national legal system, and it will be a success because many victims and people show much interest and follow it every day,” he said.

The tribunal is tasked with more than just trying former leaders of the regime.

“What we have done is not only seek justice, but national reconciliation,” said Neou Kassie, an outreach officer of the court’s Victims Unit. “Because we believe that there is reconciliation, no hatred, and no anger, we can make our country and our economy prosperous.”

Duch, who has been in detention for more than a decade, first in a military prison and then under the tribunal, faces atrocity crimes charges for his role as head of several Khmer Rouge prison facilities, including Tuol Sleng, where he is accused of overseeing the deaths of more than 12,000 people.

But while it may have had something to teach the courts, the trial was held under the shadow of lingering corruption allegations within the tribunal, engendering skepticism in some.

“I have seen that in the past few years since its inception, the court has been accused of corruption and other issues related to its transparency, and I wonder whether such a problem it is not a good example for our Cambodian court,” said Sophal Ear, a Cambodian-US professor who recently filed a victim complaint with the court.

“We didn’t learn much that we didn’t already know,” said Peter Maguire, author of “Facing Death in Cambodia.”

Still, “people are beginning to talk and beginning to think about the Khmer Rouge era,” he said. “That’s a useful thing. But I think it is a difficult thing to predict what these trials can do. In the case of Duch, I think they took too long and spent far too much money on a very simple war-crime case.”


Download Men Kimseng report aired 05 November 2009 Part I (5.89 MB)
Download  (MP3)
Listen to This Report Men Kimseng report aired 05 November 2009 Part I (5.89 MB)
Listen (MP3)
Download Men Kimseng report aired 06 November 2009 Part II (1.97 MB)
Download  (MP3)
Listen to This Report Men Kimseng report aired 06 November 2009 Part II (1.97 MB)
Listen (MP3)
E-mail This Article E-mail this article
Print This Article Print Version
  Cambodia News

  More Stories
Seven villagers charged in Kampong Thom land dispute  Audio Clip Available
First Miss Landmine Cambodia Crowned  Audio Clip Available
First Cambodian American to run for US Congress  Audio Clip Available
Fire Destroys over 200 Houses  Audio Clip Available
Seven Arrested in A Chronic Kampong Thom Land Dispute  Audio Clip Available
Opposition Blames Hun Sen for Border Encroachment  Audio Clip Available
Massage Offers Blind Cambodians Way Out of Poverty  Video clip available
Land Dispute in Kampong Thom Leads to Violence and Arrests  Audio Clip Available
Silencing Opposition,  A Threat to Cambodia Democracy: US Congressman  Audio Clip Available
Villagers Oppose Coastal Backfill Plan and Leaflets are Seized  Audio Clip Available
Counterfeit Drugs Trouble Asia, officials say at Phnom Penh conference  Audio Clip Available
Opposition leader seeks international support on immunity  Audio Clip Available
Cambodia caught between Thai internal politics, official  Audio Clip Available
Accused Thai spy received visitors  Audio Clip Available
Visit to detained Thai man allowed, officials  Audio Clip Available
Biased investigation is merely a joke: judge  Audio Clip Available
Miss Cambodia Landmine 2009 to boost self esteem  Audio Clip Available
US asked to take tough action on Cambodian human rights  Audio Clip Available
Two senior Khmer Rouge leaders to stay another year in detention  Audio Clip Available
No Cambodian-Thai dispute raised at a meeting with Obama  Audio Clip Available
UN, Cambodian Officials Meet Over Tribunal  Audio Clip Available
National Assembly To Pull Sam Rainsy Immunity  Audio Clip Available
Thaksin Visit Marks Low in Bilateral Relations: Analysts  Audio Clip Available
Cambodia Refuses Thai Request to Extradite Former Leader Thaksin Shinawatra  Audio Clip Available
Cambodia Rejects Extradition Request for Thaksin  Audio Clip Available
Thaksin Shinawatra Arrives in Cambodia as Thai Government Moves for Extradition  Audio Clip Available
Officials Sue Sam Rainsy for Incitement, Destruction  Audio Clip Available
Journalist Lauds Cambodian Media Ethics  Audio Clip Available
Cambodia's Garment Workers Hit by Recession  Video clip available
Duch’s Case Could Hold Valuable Lessons  Audio Clip Available
.Two Decades of Resource Development Questioned
Group Seeks to Keep Cambodian Arts Alive