|
|
|
Write or Wrong: The Death of Handwriting?
|
A literacy expert explains why good penmanship is still important in school. Yet most U.S. teachers consider themselves unprepared to teach it. Transcript of radio broadcast:
29 October 2009
|
|
This is the VOA Special English Education Report.
Do
American children still learn handwriting in school? In this age of the
keyboard, some people seem to think handwriting lessons are on the way out.
We asked a literacy professor at Vanderbilt University
in Nashville, Tennessee. Steve Graham says he has been hearing about the death
of handwriting for the past fifteen years. So is it still being taught?
STEVE GRAHAM: "If the results of a survey we had
published this year are accurate, it is being taught by about ninety percent of
teachers in grades one to three."
Ninety percent of teachers also say they are required
to teach handwriting. But studies have yet to answer the question of how well
they are teaching it. Professor Graham says one study published this year found
that about three out of every four teachers say they are
not prepared to teach handwriting.
STEVE GRAHAM: "And then when you look at how it's
taught, you have some teachers who are teaching handwriting by providing
instruction for ten, fifteen minutes a day, and then other teachers who
basically teach it for sixty to seventy minutes a day -- which really for
handwriting is pretty much death."
Many adults remember
learning that way -- by copying letters over and over again. Today's thinking
is that short periods of practice are better. Many experts also think
handwriting should not be taught by itself. Instead, they say it should be used
as a way to get students to express ideas. After all, that is why we write.
Professor
Graham says handwriting involves two skills. One is legibility, which means
forming the letters so they can be read. The other is fluency -- writing without
having to think about it. The professor says fluency continues to develop up
until high school.
But not everyone masters these skills. Teachers
commonly report that about one-fourth of their kids have poor handwriting. Some
people might think handwriting is not important anymore because of computers
and voice recognition programs.
But
Steve Graham at Vanderbilt says word processing is rarely done in elementary
school, especially in the early years.
STEVE GRAHAM: "Even with high school teachers, we
find that less than fifty percent of assignments are done via word processing
or with word processing. And, in fact, if we added in taking notes and doing tests
in class, most of the writing done in school is done by hand."
American
children traditionally first learn to print, then to write in cursive, which
connects the letters. But guess what we learned from a spokeswoman for the
College Board, which administers the SAT college admission test. More than
seventy-five percent of students choose to print their essay on the test rather
than write in cursive. And
that's the VOA Special English Education Report, written by Nancy Steinbach. To
learn more about handwriting research, and to share comments, go to
voaspecialenglish.com. I'm Steve Ember.
Comments:
1. time is changing
time is changing and handwriting will also effect this reality. İn our time we are using electronic assıgnment anymore. I think it will stay being just nostalgia not in further time but soon
Submitted by: Ahmet Fatih (TURKEY)
11-19-2009 - 20:19:08
2. handwriting
i think that hand writing is very important for students. for example if one of your friends send you a letter and becomes you very difficulty to read it, because his hand writing is not good and he needs more hand writing.
Submitted by: ahmed (somlia/ bossaso)
11-19-2009 - 14:09:26
3. Handwriting brings some inspiration
Every time i do my assignment I always hand-write it. It brings me more inspiration. so I think handwriting will never die!
Submitted by: ayu nisa ardiana (Indonesia)
11-09-2009 - 19:13:19
4. Handwriting
My son, who is in first grade, has had minimal instruction in handwriting since attending Pre-Kindergarten two years ago. Still, he is expected to write stories using capital and lower-case letters and correct punctuation! Needless to say, he has become very frustrated with the process, as have many of his peers. As an educator myself, I believe it is idiotic to expect young children to perform a complex task such as handwriting when it has not been formally taught to them. The teachers at my son's school say that they are not expected to provide a handwriting curriculum, since they must spend so much time teaching reading, writing (yes, writing but not handwriting!) and arithmetic in order to meet state standards. Whoever is setting these standards is not thinking clearly about their necessary components.
Submitted by: Kristen Rigney (USA)
11-08-2009 - 16:52:17
5. Education
In Cambodia, handwriting is a crucial part which every student start to learn when they go into first grade
Submitted by: Socheat (Cambodia)
11-08-2009 - 06:49:12
6. thankyou
thank you for this information
Submitted by: zana (Iraq)
11-06-2009 - 18:15:10
7. handwriting
Though it is computer era, handwriting plays a vital role in our daily activities. In some countries like Afghanistan much importance is paid on handwriting. Handwriting is a part of our culture and people think that the persons whose handwriting is good are well-educated and famous and they feel proud for that.
Submitted by: ahmad jawad kakar (Afghanistan)
11-05-2009 - 07:22:41
8. handwriting
Hand writing should be learn in the early age. either their family learn them to write litters and ahead to write words or in the beginning of the elementarily school.family and teachers should be work together to improve education of handwriting.
Submitted by: waleed (yemen)
11-05-2009 - 06:15:50
9. importance of handwriting
As an English teacher, I think handwriting is very important because if we don't practice handwriting, our handwriting will get worse and worse day by day. If we are asked to write something by hand and we do and send them to others. Others will think that we are not literate enough because in most countries people are known by their handwriting especially, in our country (Afghanistan)
Submitted by: fawad kakar (Afghanistan)
11-05-2009 - 05:28:34
10. Handwriting,
Handwriting is a wonderful part of daily life and spiritually. When we received a greeting card or a handwriting letter, we will happier to read then an email. I think handwriting is very important, we should keep it.
Submitted by: Kim Hong Ta (Canada)
11-05-2009 - 01:08:14
11. Handwriting
I taught high school briefly recently and noticed that only some of the students wrote out their assignments using cursive. Most printed out their words. When I try writing things out in block letters like they did, it cramps my hand!
I do not think I am alone in thinking that handwriting needs to be emphasized in school throughout a student's life. It is so much easier and faster. I think if a student masters it, he or she will enjoy writing a lot more.
My vote is: keep on teaching cursive, and reward students for using it in every grade.
Submitted by: Elizabeth Sheppard (USA)
11-04-2009 - 19:39:49
12.
I did learn cursive in the early 90s and we did it a bunch in school but I prefer to print. I can write faster, more legibly than if I were writing fast using cursive. And it looks fine.
Cursive handwriting is not an art. Calligraphy is an art but it's impractical to write like that unless it's for the purpose of art. Also, special pens are needed for calligraphy.
Submitted by: John
11-04-2009 - 18:02:57
13. re;killing hand writing.
writing is an art of showing the creativeness of the mind,mood and the physical health condition of a writer.ideas flow quite easily in handwriting.we are told in our moral lessons that it is bad to use the hand we use to clean our anus to eat food.it is better to use our right hand while writing as well,instead of both.marrying letters in cursive writing is an indication of divine ones of creation and any device separating the art in humanity is like separating a weak body from communicating in children sand drill, at sick bay or old age will scribing.
Submitted by: Mustapha Habib (Nigeria)
11-04-2009 - 13:18:28
14. Feedback
I do not think handwriting is important for Latin letters. Yet it does mean a lot for Asian letters. It has become a kind of art in China.
Submitted by: hongxinx (China)
11-04-2009 - 01:56:37
15. Death of Handwritting
As a classroom teacher, I must say that I think handwriting is so very important. It is true, teachers teach the basics in the early years, but as the students progress, the teachers don't push cursive. I believe this is so wrong. I make my students write in cursive. If all teachers would insist that children cursive write, then their handwriting would improve. Technology has changed the landscape not only in business, but in education too. But, technology is not the answer for everything. Handwriting is an expression of the person and I believe one can tell a lot from their handwriting. Let us all take the charge and insist that handwriting stay the main form of writing in schools.
Submitted by: clyde self (United States of America)
11-01-2009 - 14:45:27
16. The art of handwriting in Vietnam
In Vietnam, there's an art of handwriting called "Thu phap" (like Calligraphy). Words're written by a special brush. And in Lunar New Year, people often buy papers with "Thu phap" words on them to present relative and friends as gifts. So surprising! How 'bout your countries?
Submitted by: Bui D. Giau (Vietnam)
11-01-2009 - 11:39:32
17. Handwritting
Importen!!!!, With handwritting We are able to know about Charateristic, altitude, culture, and adjective everyone, so write....and write! with yourhand.
Submitted by: Raja Langit Muhammad Abdul Aziz Taqqiuddin Al Bantany (Indonesia, Banten)
11-01-2009 - 06:00:50
18. reincarnation
I still have hope for handwriting, simply because I find the keyboard so dull and so "flat". I came across some interesting piece of technology recently which really made my day:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FtY6gbjkrSs
Will handwriting be fashionable again via new technologies? Long life to handwriting! (in its new digitized reincarnation) :-)
Submitted by: Frank
10-31-2009 - 23:34:27
19. support handwritting
Some people say your handwriting partly reflects yourself. i dont know if it s true or not. However,i myself think that handwriting skills are still necessary. i still keep the habit of writing letters to my friends. i feel comfortable about it. Some say that my handwriting is good and im proud of this.
Submitted by: Minh Tam Do (Viet Nam)
10-31-2009 - 15:47:41
20.
very beatıful
Submitted by: ümmü hilal (turkey)
10-31-2009 - 14:46:52
21. handwriting
If electronics have killed good handwriting, maybe electronics can revive it. In late November, there will launch a software called "BetterLetters" that teaches handwriting with the iPhone mobile phone. You can learn more about this at http://bit.ly/BetterLetters .
Submitted by: Kate Gladstone (USA)
10-31-2009 - 03:55:43
22. Handwriting - as a part of culture
Handwriting is a part of human culture, so it will be a mistake to let it go. Look at great Chinese culture and their art of calligraphy ...
Submitted by: Andrey
10-30-2009 - 10:14:01
23. Handwriting,
In the age of computerizing, people have not care much about handwriting. I still remember when I was a little girl and started learning, my first teacher at school trained us carefully about handwriting, she not only taught us how to write but also make us understand that handwriting was very important to a student. Through handwriting, people can know our personality and virtue. Handwriting can also show our way of life and intelligence. In the time of keyboard, teachers nowadays often belittle about teaching handwriting. Students are in front of the computer all day so they think that handwriting is unnecessary and useless. If you have time, please visit an exhibition of calligraphy, you will see that handwriting is not only for reading, through the way it is written you will find something soulful and spiritually valued...
Submitted by: Autumn leaf (Viet Nam)
10-30-2009 - 05:49:50
24. It's essential
Handwriting is essetial for being in humanity, I guess.Only human being can do it. Moreover by learning it, they would grow up.
Submitted by: lee dong il (South Korea)
10-30-2009 - 00:21:50
25. my friend's cursive style
Thanks for this program.
when I was in high-school, my friends took a note in cursive style in our English class. I can't read his words and I think he is very skillful.
This program recalls such a memory to me.
Submitted by: Sillte (Japan)
10-29-2009 - 23:07:20
26. The Death of Handwriting?
I found very interesting this article, and I think the handwriting is something everyone should learn at school, because it helps to develop ideas and thinking, and most of all the hands motriz ability.
Submitted by: Mario Cruz (El Salvador)
10-29-2009 - 16:28:55
27. handwriting `
The technique just to studie 15 minutes is great since, so children can learned in a good way not going to die, but it's not will use frequently. thank you bye.
Submitted by: carlos chacon (El savador)
10-29-2009 - 16:28:04
28. the death of handwriting
i think in these days people think that writing is not very important as it was before because the tecnology that exist in our days like computers
Submitted by: beatriz privado barahona (el salvador)
10-29-2009 - 16:27:30
29. Handwriting
It is a good report because that means we have to improve our handwriting and we have to teach this to children for the future
Submitted by: Alex (El Salvador)
10-29-2009 - 16:26:59
30. handwriting
It is very important i this days to teach the new generation how important it is to write the words in the proper way it is not just about the quality of how you write it is the ortografy as well, since this is what represents you in a letter or a report that you'll write.
Submitted by: Army (El Salvador)
10-29-2009 - 16:26:58
31.
I really think the handwriting it's over, and I don't know why it's so important the hand writing, because you can express your ideas and have fluency writing on a keyboard or just speaking, In this point, I think it's most important the reading habilities.....
Submitted by: Khriz
10-29-2009 - 16:26:41
32.
I think it's very important that children do learn to write intead of just using the computer to write everything, because if you write a letter to someone with your own handwriting it's look like put an extra effor than just to print it.
Submitted by: David Luna (El Salvador)
10-29-2009 - 16:26:24
33. iTS HARD
Well i think that when i was at kindergarden they show us first how to hand writting, but now with all this technology the children dont paty attention about the handwritting.
Submitted by: Ever the elegant (EL SALVADOR)
10-29-2009 - 16:26:11
34. opinion about..
I like steve Ember!!!!! best reporter of special english:)
Submitted by: matsatso (tbilisi)
10-29-2009 - 16:08:52
35. comment on death of handwritting
hi.
Please try to teach them to write.. this is also like an art.. you know we can draw pictures in computer, but it will nt be a best art... whne we use the fingurs to write or draw.. i think it gets the help from our brain in a special way than when we use key boards.. so i hope handwriting should not be dead.
thanks
Submitted by: nilmini (Sri Lanka)
10-29-2009 - 13:05:44
36. Feedback
Interesting piece of news!
Submitted by: Rogerio Costa (Brazil)
10-29-2009 - 11:51:00
Send Us Your Comments
Submit your comments about this article. We will not publish your e-mail address. Comments will not appear until they are read and approved by an editor.
By using this form you agree to the following: All comments will be reviewed before posting. Be aware - not all submissions will be posted. VOA has the right to use your comments worldwide in any VOA produced media. Terms & Conditions.
|
|
|