VOANews.com

 
News in 45 Languages
Seeking Opinions on Health Reform, and Getting an Earful

13 August 2009

This is the VOA Special English Economics Report.

President Obama is letting Congress write the details of his plan for what he calls health insurance reform. Congress is now on its August break. But members have been holding what are known as town hall meetings around the country to hear reaction. And they have been getting an earful from crowds for and against the plan.

SOUND: "This is not health reform, this is control! Control over our lives!"

A woman expressing her opposition to health care reform during a town hall meeting in Alhambra, California on Tuesday
Expressions of opinion about health care reform at a town hall meeting in Alhambra, California
The president, at his own meetings, pointed back to the nineteen nineties.

BARACK OBAMA: "Every time we come close to passing health insurance reform, the special interests fight back with everything they've got. They use their influence. They use their political allies to scare and mislead the American people. They start running ads. This is what they always do"

But some objections are based on cost estimates from an independent agency, the Congressional Budget Office. Also, some people say they have not gotten enough details of the plan to be able to make up their minds.

Two goals are to expand health insurance to millions of Americans who do not have it, and to control rising costs for those who do. A public insurance plan is proposed to compete with private insurance companies. Republicans and other critics say the Democrats' idea of reforms would lead to socialized health care.

But one of the first groups to support the administration was the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America. PhRMA is spending millions on advertising to support the plan

The industry group has already promised to cut drug costs by eighty billion dollars over ten years. Critics want more. Some liberal lawmakers have proposed measures such as letting the government negotiate lower drug prices. But under the PhRMA deal, the chances for additional cost-saving measures are unclear.

Drugs that need a doctor's prescription became a bigger part of the debate over health care costs in two thousand three. Congress and President George W. Bush added prescription drugs to the Medicare insurance program for older Americans. That raised the costs of Medicare, which represented fifteen percent of the federal budget last year.

But PhRMA says drug costs are only ten percent of all health care costs in America. It also points out the high costs of developing new drugs.

Yet researchers from Stanford University say new treatments are often no better than existing ones, but are almost always more costly. Writing for the New England Journal of Medicine, they suggest a way to lower prices. They say the government should require drug makers to state, in their labeling information, how new medications compare with existing ones.

And that's the VOA Special English Economics Report, written by Mario Ritter. I'm Steve Ember.



Comments:

1. Necessary Reform

I am not the U.S. citizen but I think what Mr. Obama is trying to do is right and necessary and moral. The fact that 47 million people have not been covered by insurance does not reflect the status of an advanced country like the U.S. After Mr. Obama's reform, American people will have more choices than before, so they will enjoy more freedom to choose between public option and private insurers. The key is how to form an equal ground for the competitions of public and private insurers.
Submitted by: Jerry Sun (China)
09-09-2009 - 08:13:34

2. Health insurance

It is too hard to satify every people.
Submitted by: Summer (China)
08-20-2009 - 12:44:04

3. HEALTH REFORM

we shold have a nation wide on health care reform. let the american people vote . for health care reform
Submitted by: william miller (U. S. A,)
08-19-2009 - 17:42:59

4. health care system

i think the health care system of Singapore is quite successful.
Submitted by: Gloriana (china)
08-18-2009 - 09:55:47

5. The US needs health reform

As a Canadian, I have never worried about insurance (about $30/mo if your company doesn't cover you, which is very rare) and with that, you never have to pay a dime. I have friends in the US who have to pay $500 month for coverage and can barely afford to pay the mortgage afterward. No idea how the do it - and for those who aren't covered, having to live in constant fear. It will change the psyche of the American people, and if you can employ a system similar to ours, you will wonder why it took so long to do so (pharmaceuticals, probably) Good luck, rooting for my American friends, Angele
Submitted by: Angele (Canada)
08-15-2009 - 05:48:43

6. 47 million uninsuers in the U. S.

It's unbelievable! But it's true. There are about 47 million of people who do not have health insurance in the U. S. Every year eighteen thousand people die because of lack of treatment. It does not make any senses at all because America is the richest and most powerful country in the world. It's not easy to get free health care if you are under 65, you are not pregnant woman,you are not a kid under 18, or you are not disable. It's not easy to get health insurance from your employer either if you are a part- time employee. That's why there so many people without heath insurance like that. However, 47 million is only about 15% of the population. It means 85% of the peole here are fine with their health care. Just some of them get sick seriously and be refused to cover by their insurance companies. Not much, I guess. That's why people are not interested in having something new, which they do not like because it sounds like socialism, and it may increase their income tax( althoug
Submitted by: Sam (Vietnam)
08-14-2009 - 23:15:18

7. Happiness

Hello my respected teachers of voaspecialenglish.com yesterday my friend asked me.how to know about American life,stories,jokes,learn english site and much more i told him for knowing american life and much more information goto voaspecialenglish.com and if u want american grammar details goto manythings.org today he saw me and he thanked me very,very much. Upto now i have joint 50 persons for using this educational site.and infact when iam sad i begin using this site than i get happiness.thanks for broadcasting and publishing this kind of site.thanks alot.ur sinecerlly Aslam himat from my sweet country Afg.
Submitted by: Aslam himat (Afghanistan)
08-14-2009 - 17:15:10

8. Healthcare,politics and drug companies

Great article, tried to explain problems faced by politicians,,health insurance companies and the common man at the receiving end of all.
Submitted by: dr l c sunda (India)
08-14-2009 - 16:34:18

9. Killers for Profit

I'm amazed at the confusion of the current health care debate. I just don't understood why any middle class American would want to accept the status quo of health care. The conservative arguments about why they would not want a government public option are the same arguments you could apply to the current health care system. What confuses me, this should not be a conservative or liberal debate. It should be a debate about what is best for Americans health needs v.s. profit orientated decisions made by insurance companies looking out for their bottom line. Rationing - health insurance companies do that now. If you have coverage and your level of sickness is beyond the expense they are willing to cover, they will drop you in a heart beat. It happens to thousands of middle class families after years of paying their premiums. They find themselves with a serious illness that is beyond the threshold of what an insurance company is willing to pay and they drop you. To stay alive your onl
Submitted by: steve (USA)
08-14-2009 - 15:57:07

10. No to Government Health Care - Simplify what we have!

Simply legalize capitalistic health insurance companies the freedom to compete with one-another across state lines with their coverage programs. Make it mandatory that age & all precondition health issues be accepted. A percentage factor could possibly be added'
Submitted by: E J ENNS (U S A)
08-14-2009 - 02:45:19

11. Health Care Reform

I don't think people really understand what's at stake here. Obama is not responsible for the economy, the wars in the Middle East or the health care system. He is however trying to turn our country around in the right direction. I don't think for one minute his administration is trying to get in the health care business. Having an option that will keep health insurance providers honest is in all of our best interest. As an American who has suffered for the past 8 years under the Bush administration I welcome open discussion that reveals the conditions our country faces. We have the opportunity to fix some serious problems with our current health care system which is directly linked to our failing economy. People email or call your local representative and ask for factual evidence to support the statements they are making for or against health care reform. Make them pay in 2010 and 2012 if they lie to you.
Submitted by: Lou (USA)
08-14-2009 - 02:17:53

12. Health Care Reform

It is crazy to see all of these folks screaming and yelling. Sure they are concerned as past legislation has meant less services and usually higher costs, but let's look at reason. A lot of other countries are doing this just fine. Do we really want a basic service to be revenue driven? Talk about "death panels". A real concern is the cost. What most need to understand is that we pay a lot of this already in the form of state programs and unpaid ER bills which are passed on to the premiums of the insured. A recent poll indicates most people are very concerned: http://www.polladium.com/poll.php?poll_id=229&location_id=1
Submitted by: Ryan D (US)
08-14-2009 - 01:58:56

13. Healt Reform

Republicans are filling the media , and the air ways, of big, lies, and ,misconceptions, of every king, trying to SCARE, all the American people, about this Reform. In this , they are playing in the hand of the Health Industry, which is the Greatest, contributor to the REPUBICAN treasure to make political campaigns. The problems are, there is some INNOCENTS ,or ignorant, who steel believe these great LIARES.
Submitted by: Rleb2002 (USA)
08-14-2009 - 01:55:39

Download MP3
(Tip: Left-click, or right-click and choose "Save...") Download  (MP3)
Listen to This Report MP3
Stream (MP3)
E-mail This Article E-mail this article
Print This Article Print Version
  Featured Story
'Family of Man' Gets a 21st Century Update  Audio Clip Available

  More Stories
Half of US Jobs Now Held by Women  Audio Clip Available
American History Series: Victory at Vicksburg Splits the Confederacy  Audio Clip Available
US Colleges Set Enrollment Record  Audio Clip Available
Jane Goodall: Still Hard at Work for the Chimps  Audio Clip Available
Debate Over New Guidelines for Breast Cancer Screening  Audio Clip Available
A Serious Study Looks at Laughter Worldwide  Audio Clip Available
Two Efforts Seek to Increase Food Security in Africa  Audio Clip Available
Project Finds New Homes for Unwanted Bikes From US  Audio Clip Available
Biltmore Estate Takes Visitors Back in Time  Audio Clip Available
Words and Their Stories: I Feel Very Blue  Audio Clip Available
Helen Keller, 1880-1968: She Became the Most Famous Disabled Person in the World  Audio Clip Available
Remembering Wars of the Past, and the Present  Audio Clip Available
Short Story: 'The Whirligig of Life' by O. Henry  Audio Clip Available