News / Asia

    Chinese Family Members Question Motive Behind MH370 Declaration

    Bao Lanfang, second from right, whose daughter-in-law, son and granddaughter were aboard Malaysia Airlines Flight 370, kneels in grief while speaking to journalists outside the company's offices in Beijing, Aug. 6, 2015.
    Bao Lanfang, second from right, whose daughter-in-law, son and granddaughter were aboard Malaysia Airlines Flight 370, kneels in grief while speaking to journalists outside the company's offices in Beijing, Aug. 6, 2015.

    Malaysia’s announcement that debris found off a French island belongs to the plane at the heart of the world’s biggest airline mystery, has done little to answer the persistent questions of Chinese families of those on board the flight.

    In Beijing, Chinese family members and relatives of those on board missing Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 say the announcement made by Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak has only fueled their anger and frustration. 

    One of their biggest concerns and questions is why the announcement was made, even when some have yet to give a final confirmation that the debris indeed belongs to MH370.

    Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak, center, gestures before speaking at a special press conference announcing the findings for the ill fated flight MH370 in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, Aug. 6, 2015.
    Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak, center, gestures before speaking at a special press conference announcing the findings for the ill fated flight MH370 in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, Aug. 6, 2015.

    'Irresponsible'

    Steve Wang, whose mother was on board the Beijing bound flight that went missing more than 500 days ago, calls the announcement irresponsible.

    “If you don’t have 100 percent (certainty), it is 99.9 percent and that it is still a might be. I don’t know why (Prime Minister) Najib wanted to give such kind of a conclusion in such a hurry,” Wang said.

    Another family member who spoke with VOA on condition of anonymity says the decision to make a hurried announcement before France issued a final conclusion is not only irresponsible, but raises questions about Malaysia’s true intentions.

    Family members say they are not in denial, but that they owe it to their loved ones to not just declare them lost without 100 percent certainty about what happened to the flight.

    Questions remain

    In his announcement, Malaysia’s prime minister said an international team of experts had “conclusively confirmed” that the debris belong to the missing plane. However, prosecutors in France, where the debris is being examined, say there is a “very strong presumption” that the portion of a wing that was found belongs to the plane.

    Chinese family members say that both French investigators and Boeing – the maker of the aircraft – should confirm that the flaperon belongs to the MH370.

    On Thursday, officials couched their comments about the development. Australia’s Foreign Minister Julie Bishop confirmed that the search for the missing plane would continue, adding that “once the French team confirms” the debris belongs to the plane, a further analysis of currents, drifts and winds would begin.

    U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry, who is in the Malaysian capital of Kuala Lumpur for a regional conference,  told reporters that the discovery of the flap on Reunion Island has once again opened wounds.

    "The U.S. hopes that the debris that was discovered on Reunion Island — if it is found to be conclusively from the aircraft — will help to bring some sense of closure," and perhaps help narrow the search area for the plane, Kerry said.

    Full investigation

    China’s Foreign Ministry expressed its sorrow and sympathy for the families of those on board and urged Malaysia to make good on its commitment to fully investigate the crash.

    "We advise Malaysia to give some further explanation to the passengers' relatives based on the development of the situation," said Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi. "I think we must give full consideration to the passengers relatives and those on board and give full consideration to the sufferings they have been through."

    Malaysian Airlines Flight MH370 disappeared on March 8, 2014 and is believed to have gone down in the Indian Ocean, nearly 4,000 kilometers away from where the debris was found on Reunion Island.

    You May Like

    Video Aid Workers Report 'Barely Moving Skeletons' in Syria's Madaya

    Humanitarian workers say plight of starving people in besieged town heartbreaking and worst they have witnessed during country's nearly 5-year-long civil war

    Fears Renewed of Islamic State Attacks in Europe, US

    IS aiming for ‘European 9/11,’ French official says; potential for disaster so great that ‘2016 is going to be the year where we wish we could get back to 2015,’ insider predicts

    Syrian Kurdish Female Fighters Expand Ranks Against IS

    Special units train women in physical fitness, weapons education and military classes; ‘We lead our lives together,’ one member said

    This forum has been closed.
    Comment Sorting
    Comments
         
    by: Echo from: China
    August 13, 2015 9:11 PM
    I feel sorry for this disaster.But the comments from this Jake (from Albuquerque) are so mean and mercifulless.What will you feel when you encounter such a disater?Show your mercy!Do not be a by-stander.Don't let your political prejudice control your understanding to human nature.

    by: Jake from Albuquerque
    August 07, 2015 4:02 AM
    I skipped the second half of this article, because I am well acquainted with Chinese propaganda: blame any/every one but the Middle Kingdom.

    It's sad that, because of a population surplus, Beijing has NO moral compass...they simply dump aggression and vitriol on anyone nearby

    The fact that so many Chinese citizens went down on this plane is being used to foment anger and keep 'face' in a country that fosters barbaric acts (such as murdering children as they are born because it's a Girl, rather than a Boy), and expresses outrage at another country's treatment of the same citizens that THEY would put to death for a 'parking infraction'.

    The ChiComms are not to be trusted.
    If this Family had deviated from the prepared script, then, they too would be facing imprisonment.
    Or worse.

    by: GH1618 from: USA
    August 06, 2015 4:27 PM
    These people are grasping at straws. It is 100% certain that MH370 went down in the southern Indian Ocean.

    Featured Videos

    Your JavaScript is turned off or you have an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.
    Bomber Targets Istanbul Tourist Areai
    X
    January 12, 2016 8:56 PM
    At least 10 people are dead after what Turkey says was an attack by a suicide bomber Tuesday in one of Istanbul’s prime tourist areas. VOA Europe correspondent Luis Ramirez reports.
    Video

    Video Bomber Targets Istanbul Tourist Area

    At least 10 people are dead after what Turkey says was an attack by a suicide bomber Tuesday in one of Istanbul’s prime tourist areas. VOA Europe correspondent Luis Ramirez reports.
    Video

    Video US Lottery Jackpot Tops $1 Billion, Shattering Records

    After another drawing without a winner, the U.S. Powerball jackpot has reached a whopping $1.5 billion — shattering all previous records. The huge jackpot has sent millions of Americans into a national state of lottery frenzy. Alberto Pimienta brings us the story.
    Video

    Video More US Sanctions Against North Korea Loom

    The U.S. House of Representatives moved closer Monday to passing a bill that will impose harsher unilateral sanctions against North Korea for conducting its fourth nuclear test last week. And in Seoul the U.S. and South Korean militaries are closely coordinating the possible buildup of assets such as aircraft, armaments and warships in the region. VOA’s Brian Padden reports from Seoul.
    Video

    Video In Kenya, Blind Students Learn Through Technology

    Until recently, blind and visually impaired students in Kenya were still using Braille books for their studies. But Kenyan schools for the blind are now beginning to adopt technology that provides material in a audible form -- and in the process expands their opportunities. Lenny Ruvaga reports from the town of Thika.
    Video

    Video Assault Allegations Aggravate EU Immigration Crisis

    Europe's immigration crisis has taken a new turn after reports that New Year's attacks on women in Cologne and other cities were organized by immigrant groups. Swedish authorities now have to answer allegations that police covered up similar attacks on women in Sweden. While a wave of migrants from Northern Africa, the Middle East and parts of Asia continues to arrive at Europe's door, governments struggle to stem the anti-immigrant sentiment in the host countries. Zlatica Hoke reports.
    Video

    Video Crippled by War, Syrian City of Homs Attempts Comeback

    Ravaged by civil war and Islamic State occupation, the battered western Syrian city of Homs is slowly rising from a crippled existence.
    Video

    Video Mozambique Refugees Fleeing to Malawi

    Malawi continues receiving hundreds of refugees from Mozambique six months after RENAMO fighters carried out two attacks in Tete province. The fighting in July forced more than 700 people into Malawi and refugees say they continue to flee atrocities and killings by militias. Lameck Masina reports for VOA from a refugee camp in Malawi's Mwanza district, home to more than 2,500 refugees who fled atrocities in Tete province.
    Video

    Video Rock Legend David Bowie Dead at 69

    Rock fans are mourning British superstar David Bowie, whose death was announced Monday after an 18-month battle with cancer. VOA Europe Correspondent Luis Ramirez reports from London, Bowie’s birthplace.
    Video

    Video Arab League Accuses Iran of Interfering in Arab Affairs, Fueling Unrest

    Arab League foreign ministers have accused Iran of interfering in Arab nations' internal affairs and fueling unrest in the region. Top Arab diplomats meeting Sunday in Cairo also condemned the Iranian government for failing to protect Saudi missions in Iran during anti-Saudi protests last week, after the execution of a prominent Shi'ite cleric in Saudi Arabia. Zlatica Hoke reports.
    Video

    Video US Gasoline Prices Low, But at a Cost

    The recent oil boom in the United States has contributed to an overall drop in gasoline prices. The boom also has increased demand for services and materials that support the hydraulic fracturing, or “fracking,” industry that extracts the oil from shale formations. But as VOA’s Kane Farabaugh reports, low oil prices are cooling off the once red-hot fracking industry — affecting many companies that have benefited from increased domestic oil production.
    Video

    Video Yemen Crisis: War Intensifies Amid Saudi-Iran Diplomatic Standoff

    The Saudi-led coalition fighting Yemen's Houthi rebels -- believed to be backed by Iran -- has intensified attacks in recent days after Iran and Saudi Arabia severed diplomatic ties in the wake of the execution of a Shi'ite Saudi cleric. And as prospects for peace talks dim, Yemenis say the fallout from fuel shortages and their deteriorating economy are taking as many lives as the war. VOA’s Heather Murdock in Cairo reports with Almigdad Mojalli in the Yemeni capital, Sana’a.
    Video

    Video IS Losing Ground One Year After Charlie Hebdo Attacks

    Parisians are marking a solemn anniversary this week. It’s been one year since the Islamic State-inspired terrorist attacks on the Charlie Hebdo satirical magazine and on a Jewish supermarket that left at total of 17 people dead. But as Linda Ringe reports, the battle against IS looks very different this January than last.