DUBAI —
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry has told his French counterpart a trip to Iran by French executives was “not helpful” and that it gave the wrong impression that the West could do business with Tehran as usual, a U.S. official said.
Under an interim deal reached by Iran and six world powers in November, Tehran agreed to limit parts of its nuclear work in return for the easing of some international sanctions.
The deal called for negotiation of a full agreement within a year. The easing of sanctions, which began in late January, has prompted Western firms to race for business opportunities.
Iran welcomed more than 100 executives from France's biggest firms on Monday, the most senior French trade mission in years.
“Secretary Kerry has talked directly to Foreign Minister [Laurent] Fabius about the trade delegation... about how this is not helpful,” Undersecretary of State for Political Affairs Wendy Sherman told U.S. lawmakers in Washington on Tuesday.
“Tehran is not open for business because our sanctions relief is quite temporary, quite limited and quite targeted,” she said.
Sherman and U.S. Treasury Undersecretary David Cohen also sought to address concerns in the Congress that too many concessions had been made to Iran in the nuclear talks.
While the initial agreement was “not perfect,” it bought time to try to secure a comprehensive deal, U.S. officials said.
In Tehran, Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif criticized comments made by Sherman at the hearing in Congress, without specifying which ones he was reacting to.
“Such talk isn't helpful and could adversely impact the [nuclear negotiations]. U.S. officials should stop such comments so that we can reach a solution,” state media quoted Zarif as saying at a joint news conference on Wednesday with the head of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, Iyad Madani.
Zarif, however, acknowledged that “some comments made by Americans are for domestic consumption”.
Private initiative
Asked about Kerry's conversation with Fabius, France's foreign ministry said the two men speak regularly and that the main French employers' association MEDEF had organized the trade delegation on its own initiative.
France, the euro zone's second largest economy, has for months vaunted an “economic diplomacy” drive to secure trade agreements abroad. However, MEDEF was behind the Iran trip.
“It was that organization's initiative, in an exploratory capacity and in compliance with France's international engagements,” the Foreign Ministry said in an online briefing.
The delegation on the Feb. 2-5 trip met Mohammad Nahavandian, President Hassan Rouhani's chief of staff, and members of Irans Chamber of Commerce, Industries, Mines and Agriculture, state news agency IRNA said.
Among the companies represented were Safran, Airbus , Total, GDF-Suez, Renault, Alcatel, Alstom and L'Oreal, a source close to the delegation said.
Pierre Gattaz, the head of MEDEF, said the delegation had not violated the terms of the interim nuclear accord.
“We faultlessly respected the Geneva Convention of last November, we're familiar with this framework. There are other European country delegations who were in Iran,” he said.
Some U.S. Congress members have said it was unwise to ease sanctions before Iran did more to curb its nuclear activity.
The U.S. ambassador to Germany, John Emerson, told a business conference on Tuesday that Iran sanctions were working, “so the worst thing that could happen is that companies that would like to do business with Iran... jump to the front of the line before we are able to conclude reach this agreement”.
If Congress begins to see “a sieve or a hole in this process,” Emerson warned, “they'll jump right in there and that could blow the negotiations up.”
Under an interim deal reached by Iran and six world powers in November, Tehran agreed to limit parts of its nuclear work in return for the easing of some international sanctions.
The deal called for negotiation of a full agreement within a year. The easing of sanctions, which began in late January, has prompted Western firms to race for business opportunities.
Iran welcomed more than 100 executives from France's biggest firms on Monday, the most senior French trade mission in years.
“Secretary Kerry has talked directly to Foreign Minister [Laurent] Fabius about the trade delegation... about how this is not helpful,” Undersecretary of State for Political Affairs Wendy Sherman told U.S. lawmakers in Washington on Tuesday.
“Tehran is not open for business because our sanctions relief is quite temporary, quite limited and quite targeted,” she said.
Sherman and U.S. Treasury Undersecretary David Cohen also sought to address concerns in the Congress that too many concessions had been made to Iran in the nuclear talks.
While the initial agreement was “not perfect,” it bought time to try to secure a comprehensive deal, U.S. officials said.
In Tehran, Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif criticized comments made by Sherman at the hearing in Congress, without specifying which ones he was reacting to.
“Such talk isn't helpful and could adversely impact the [nuclear negotiations]. U.S. officials should stop such comments so that we can reach a solution,” state media quoted Zarif as saying at a joint news conference on Wednesday with the head of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, Iyad Madani.
Zarif, however, acknowledged that “some comments made by Americans are for domestic consumption”.
Private initiative
Asked about Kerry's conversation with Fabius, France's foreign ministry said the two men speak regularly and that the main French employers' association MEDEF had organized the trade delegation on its own initiative.
France, the euro zone's second largest economy, has for months vaunted an “economic diplomacy” drive to secure trade agreements abroad. However, MEDEF was behind the Iran trip.
“It was that organization's initiative, in an exploratory capacity and in compliance with France's international engagements,” the Foreign Ministry said in an online briefing.
The delegation on the Feb. 2-5 trip met Mohammad Nahavandian, President Hassan Rouhani's chief of staff, and members of Irans Chamber of Commerce, Industries, Mines and Agriculture, state news agency IRNA said.
Among the companies represented were Safran, Airbus , Total, GDF-Suez, Renault, Alcatel, Alstom and L'Oreal, a source close to the delegation said.
Pierre Gattaz, the head of MEDEF, said the delegation had not violated the terms of the interim nuclear accord.
“We faultlessly respected the Geneva Convention of last November, we're familiar with this framework. There are other European country delegations who were in Iran,” he said.
Some U.S. Congress members have said it was unwise to ease sanctions before Iran did more to curb its nuclear activity.
The U.S. ambassador to Germany, John Emerson, told a business conference on Tuesday that Iran sanctions were working, “so the worst thing that could happen is that companies that would like to do business with Iran... jump to the front of the line before we are able to conclude reach this agreement”.
If Congress begins to see “a sieve or a hole in this process,” Emerson warned, “they'll jump right in there and that could blow the negotiations up.”
