News

Study: Most Organic Crops Fall Short on Yields

Lower yields means feeding world organically requires clearing more land

A new study shows organic crops typically yield less than those raised with artificial fertilizers and pesticides.
A new study shows organic crops typically yield less than those raised with artificial fertilizers and pesticides.

Some organic crops produce nearly as much as conventional agriculture, but most still fall short, according to a new analysis.  

With a growing world population and limited land available to feed it, the study has implications for the debate on how to feed the world sustainably.

But some note there is more to sustainability than just crop yields.

Organic advocates say farming without artificial fertilizers and pesticides has less environmental impact.

But skeptics note organic farming generally produces less food per hectare. Lower yields means feeding the world organically would require clearing more land. Deforestation for agriculture is already a major contributor to climate change and biodiversity loss.

The new study in Nature looks at how big the gap is between conventional and organic yields.

More productive

The study combines 66 earlier yield studies. “Conventional yields are typically higher than organic yields, but with certain management practices, certain environmental conditions, and certain crop species this yield difference can be quite small,” says lead author and McGill University researcher Verena Seufert.

On average, organic crops produced 25 percent less than conventional.

Vegetables and cereal crops (maize and wheat, for example) performed worse: 33 and 26 percent, respectively. But organic fruits and other perennials nearly matched conventional yields. So did legume crops like soybeans that produce some of their own fertilizer.

The organic penalty was smaller on organic farms that relied on rainfall, which were 17 percent less productive, compared to irrigated farms, which fell behind by 35 percent.

“Under rainfed conditions where water supply varies depending on weather conditions, the organic soil can actually provide water better to the crops because it can capture and maintain this water for longer,” Seufert says.

Harder to manage

One area where organic farmers could improve, she says, is giving their crops enough nitrogen fertilizer. Those that received more nitrogen had smaller yield differences, she says.

But that’s harder to do organically with just manure and crop rotations, she says.

“In conventional agriculture, you just dump inorganic nitrogen fertilizer on the plants and they grow; while in organic agriculture, you need to manage the system. You need to manage the soil. You need to improve the soil quality,” Seufert says.

And besides fertilizers, farms that also used industry-standard best management practices for weeds and pests reached nearly 90 percent of conventional yields.

Land issue

If organic crops were given the right amount of nutrients and protected from weeds and pests, they could produce the same amount as conventional crops, says agronomist Ken Cassman at the University of Nebraska at Lincoln.

But he says that’s not the issue.  

“The problem is the land issue, if you’re talking global food security,” he says. “Because either you’ve got to have [a] longer [crop] rotation or you have to bring nutrients from outside the system somehow.”

Organic farmers rotate food crops with plants that fertilize the soil. But while fertilizer crops are growing, food crops are not. So food has to be grown somewhere else.

Or farmers fertilizer with manure. But it takes grazing land or crop land to feed the animals that make the manure.

The world’s food demand will grow by 70 percent by mid-century, according to the United Nations. Cassman says researchers need to figure out how to meet the demand on the same amount of land that farmers are using today.

“There really isn’t much good land left that’s not, for instance, rainforest, or wetlands, or grassland savannah, which are the last carbon-rich and biodiverse regions that we have,” he says.

Hybrid farming

“I think when people see these studies, their first reaction is, ‘Well, my goodness, organic farming can’t feed the world,’” says Washington State University soil scientist John Reganold. “Guess what? Conventional farming cannot sustainably feed the world.”

He says it takes a lot of energy to make artificial fertilizer, and experts say some key ingredients are running out.

And he adds that sustainability means more than just producing high yields, according to the U.S. National Academy of Sciences. The environment, social justice and economic viability are important, too.

He says organic and conventional systems are bookends - extremes at opposite ends of the spectrum. He says more and more, farming is becoming a hybrid of both.

The University of Nebraska's Ken Cassman says the arguments over ideology are a distraction.

“You don’t focus on whether organic is better or conventional is better,” he says. “You simply focus on the outcome.”

“In my personal food decisions, I have a mix," says study author Verena Seufert. "And I think we do have to have to have that on a larger scale.”

This forum has been closed.
Comments
     
There are no comments in this forum. Be first and add one

Featured Videos

Your JavaScript is turned off or you have an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.
Drowned Migrant Toddler Photo Triggers European Outragei
X
Henry Ridgwell
September 04, 2015 11:36 AM
The harrowing picture of a drowned three-year-old Syrian boy washed up on a Turkish beach appears to have galvanized Europe’s leaders into doing more to address the refugee crisis. France, Germany and Italy issued a joint call Thursday for compulsory quotas of refugees for all EU states. But there were chaotic scenes in Hungary as police tried to force migrants off a train heading for Austria. Henry Ridgwell has more. And a caution, some of the images in this report may be disturbing.
Video

Video Drowned Migrant Toddler Photo Triggers European Outrage

The harrowing picture of a drowned three-year-old Syrian boy washed up on a Turkish beach appears to have galvanized Europe’s leaders into doing more to address the refugee crisis. France, Germany and Italy issued a joint call Thursday for compulsory quotas of refugees for all EU states. But there were chaotic scenes in Hungary as police tried to force migrants off a train heading for Austria. Henry Ridgwell has more. And a caution, some of the images in this report may be disturbing.
Video

Video Russians Observe 11th Anniversary of Beslan School Attack

This week, Russians have been observing the 11th anniversary of the attack by Islamic militants on a school in Russia's North Caucasus region that killed more than 330 hostages, including 186 children. The three-day siege and massacre that started on September 1, 2004 took place in Beslan, a town in the republic of North Ossetia, and is one of the bloodiest terrorist acts ever in Russia. VOA's Mike Richman reports.
Video

Video Native Americans Debate: Father Serra, Saint or Sinner?

Pope Francis will canonize an 18th century missionary to Spanish California during a papal visit to the United States this month.  But some Native Americans have criticized the elevation to sainthood of the missionary priest, Junipero Serra. VOA's Mike O’Sullivan has more from Los Angeles.
Video

Video Calais School Offers Another Face of Europe’s Migrant Crisis

Europe is facing mounting criticism over how it’s handling its biggest migration crisis since World War II. But not all Europeans believe building walls or passing repressive policies are the answer. A school for migrants in the French port city of Calais, is opening doors and building bonds across nationalities. VOA's Lisa Bryant reports.
Video

Video Kurdish Fighters on IS Frontline Ready for Offensive

Finger on the trigger, the Kurdish Peshmerga soldier stared across the dust at a village taken over by Islamic State extremists. The Kurdistan’s Khazir frontline, just 45 minutes from the Islamic State stronghold of Mosul. And at this point, the militants were less than two kilometers away. VOA's Sharon Behn reports.
Video

Video China Announces Troop Cuts at WWII Parade

Chinese President Xi Jinping Thursday announced plans to cut the world’s largest military force by 300,000 troops. The announcement was made during a massive military parade to commemorate victory over Japan in World War II. The event was shunned by most Western leaders and for some is raising fresh concerns about China’s military ambitions. VOA’s Bill Ide has more from Beijing.
Video

Video Russia-Japan Relations Cool as Putin Visits China for WWII Anniversary

Russian President Vladimir Putin is in Beijing for commemorations of the 70th anniversary of China's WWII victory over Japan. Putin is expected to visit Japan later this year, but tensions between Tokyo and Moscow over islands disputed since the war, and sanctions over Ukraine, could pour cold water on the plan. VOA's Daniel Schearf reports.
Video

Video Yemen ‘on Brink of Disaster’ as Medical Shortages Soar

Aid agencies warn Yemen is on the brink of humanitarian disaster – with up to half a million children facing severe malnutrition, and hospitals running out of basic medicines. There are fears Yemen's civil war could escalate as the coalition led by Saudi Arabia tries to drive back Houthi rebels, who seized control of much of the country earlier this year. Henry Ridgwell reports.
Video

Video Apps Helping Kenyan Businesses Stay Ahead of Counterfeiters

Counterfeit goods in Kenya cost the government as much as $1 billion each year in lost tax revenues. The fake goods also hurt entrepreneurs who find it hard to carve out a niche in the market and retain customers. But as Lenny Ruvaga reports from Nairobi, information technology is being used to try to beat the problem.
Video

Video Nobel Prize Winner Malala Talks to VOA

Nobel Peace Prize winner Malala Yousafzai met with VOA's Deewa service in Washington Sunday to talk about women’s rights and unveil a trailer for her new documentary. VOA's Katherine Gypson has more.
Video

Video War, Drought Threaten Iraq's Marshlands

Iraq's southern wetlands are in crisis. These areas are the spawning ground for Gulf fisheries, a resting place for migrating wildfowl, and source of livelihood for fishermen and herders. Faith Lapidus has more.
Video

Video Colombians Flee Venezuela as Border Crisis Escalates

Hundreds of Colombians have fled Venezuela since last week, amid an escalating border crisis between the two countries. Last week, Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro ordered the closure of a key border crossing after smugglers injured three Venezuelan soldiers and a civilian. The president also ordered the deportation of Colombians who are in Venezuela illegally. Zlatica Hoke reports.
Video

Video Rebuilding New Orleans' Music Scene

Ten years after Hurricane Katrina inundated New Orleans, threatening to wash away its vibrant musical heritage along with its neighborhoods, the beat goes on. As Bronwyn Benito and Faith Lapidus report, a Musicians' Village is preserving the city's unique sound.
Video

Video In Russia, Auto Industry in Tailspin

Industry insiders say country relies too heavily on imports as inflation cuts too many consumers out of the market. Daniel Schearf has more from Moscow.
Video

Video Scientist Calls Use of Fetal Tissue in Medical Research Essential

An anti-abortion group responsible for secret recordings of workers at a women's health care organization claims the workers shown are offering baby parts for sale, a charge the organization strongly denies. While the selling of fetal tissue is against the law in the United States, abortion and the use of donated fetal tissue for medical research are both legal. VOA’s Julie Taboh reports.

VOA Blogs