News / USA

    Without Scalia, Supreme Court Divided on Key Police Powers Case

    FILE - Cook County Sheriff police officers in Chicago, Illinois search a vehicle and a woman at street stop in the city's Austin neighborhood, September 9, 2015.
    FILE - Cook County Sheriff police officers in Chicago, Illinois search a vehicle and a woman at street stop in the city's Austin neighborhood, September 9, 2015.

    On its first day back at work since Justice Antonin Scalia's unexpected death, the U.S. Supreme Court plunged into a case that could profoundly influence police behavior and alter the increasingly tense relationship between law enforcement and the public in high-crime urban areas.

    The eight remaining justices appeared divided along familiar ideological lines, raising the specter of what some predict could be a number of 4-4 votes without Scalia.

    At issue in this case, Utah v. Strieff, is whether courts can admit evidence obtained in a police search based on an earlier arrest warrant that is discovered only after a suspect is detained without probable cause.

    The justices heard an appeal filed by Utah officials of a ruling by the state's top court in favor of Edward Strieff, who was convicted in 2006 of methamphetamine possession and a related drug charge after his vehicle was stopped by police in Salt Lake City.

    The state Supreme Court ruled that Strieff's rights under the U.S. Constitution's Fourth Amendment were violated because although there was a warrant issued for his arrest at the time of the search — for a minor traffic violation — the police officer did not know that when he stopped Strieff's vehicle.

    FILE - Protesters gather during a demonstration in Ferguson, Missouri, Aug. 11, 2015. Justice Sonia Sotomayor linked the Utah v. Strieff case to heavy-handed police tactics in minority communities like Ferguson.
    FILE - Protesters gather during a demonstration in Ferguson, Missouri, Aug. 11, 2015. Justice Sonia Sotomayor linked the Utah v. Strieff case to heavy-handed police tactics in minority communities like Ferguson.

    That concerned Justice Sonia Sotomayor, who linked the Strieff case to heavy-handed police tactics in minority communities like Ferguson, Missouri — the St. Louis suburb where Michael Brown, an unarmed black teenager, was shot and killed in August 2014 by a white police officer during a street confrontation.

    The shooting prompted protests that shook the area for weeks.

    "If you have a town like Ferguson, where 80 percent of the residents have [minor] traffic warrants out, there may be a very good incentive for just standing on the street corner and asking every citizen, give me your ID," Sotomayor said.

    "What stops us from becoming a police state?" she asked Utah Solicitor General Tyler Green, who conceded that Strieff's Fourth Amendment protections were violated.

    Acting in good faith

    Joan Watt, representing Strieff, argued that the arresting officer lacked reasonable cause to stop him, because the officer only saw him coming out of a house under surveillance for drug activity, but did not see him enter or do anything illegal.

    But John Bash, assistant to the solicitor general of the U.S. Department of Justice, countered that any taint on the evidence secured via the illegal stop was diminished because the arrest was not a flagrant violation of the Fourth Amendment and falls under a commonly cited exception to its protections.

    Bash said the arresting officer, Detective Douglas Fackrell, acted in good faith and had reasonable cause to stop Strieff based on what he observed going on at the house.

    Fackrell "saw short-term traffic that was consistent in his experience and expertise with drug activity. And then someone walked out of the house ... I mean, this wasn't a pizza deliveryman," Bash said.

    Thirty other states — including Michigan, Oregon, Kansas, Florida and Hawaii — agreed.

    They filed an Amicus Brief in support of Utah, arguing that suppressing evidence found in such circumstances would neuter the power of legal arrest warrants and frustrate police officers' ability to perform their duties.

    Kagan counters

    But Justice Elena Kagan countered that creating a new standard for Fourth Amendment protections would change police incentives dramatically in communities where large numbers of people have arrest warrants.

    "In these very heavily policed areas — I mean, I was staggered by the number of arrest warrants that are out on people," Kagan said.

    "So it's a significant possibility that you're going to find an arrest warrant and be able to admit whatever drugs or guns or whatever it is you find," she said.

    Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito appeared unmoved, arguing that law enforcement officers have many reasons to run warrant checks, including fears for their personal safety after traffic stops.

    Watt was undeterred.

    "Utah's rule would have an overwhelming impact that would create a powerful incentive for police officers to walk up to people on the street and simply stop them," she answered.

    The court is expected to issue a decision on the case before the end of its term in June.


    Mark Snowiss

    Mark Snowiss is a Washington D.C.-based multimedia reporter.  He has written and edited for various media outlets including Pacifica and NPR affiliates in Los Angeles. Follow him on Twitter @msnowiss and on Google Plus

    You May Like

    In Britain, The Sun Still Doesn’t Shine

    Invoking Spitfires and Merlin, Leave voters insist country can be great again, following surprising 'Brexit' vote last week

    Double Wave of Suicide Bombings Puts Lebanon, Refugees on Edge

    Following suicide bombings in Christian town of Al-Qaa, on Lebanon's northeast border with Syria, fears of further bombings have risen

    US Senators Warned on Zika After Failing to Pass Funding

    Zika threats and challenges, as well as issues of contraception and vaccines, spelled out as lawmakers point fingers

    This forum has been closed.
    Comment Sorting
    Comments
         
    by: meanbill from: USA
    February 22, 2016 11:05 PM
    Remember? .. Supreme Court Justices Sotomayor and Kagan both were selected to be Supreme Court Justices by Obama under his own (history recorded) personal criterion, (that they have empathy for young teenage moms, the poor, African-Americans, or gays, or disabled, or old, in making their judicial decisions), and nobody should be surprised now, when all their judicial decisions are predicated on the premise made to Obama, even though their promise to Obama contradicts their Supreme Court Justice Oath?

    [Judicial Oath of Supreme Court Justices] .. "I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will administer justice without respect to persons, and do equal right to the poor and the rich, and that I will faithfully and impartially discharge and perform all the duties incumbent on me as under the constitution and laws of the United States." _ So help me God."

    Featured Videos

    Your JavaScript is turned off or you have an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.
    Slow Rebuilding Amid Boko Haram Destruction in Nigeria’s Northeasti
    X
    June 29, 2016 6:15 PM
    Military operations have chased Boko Haram out of towns and cities in Nigeria’s northeast since early last year. But it is only recently that people have begun returning to their homes in Adamawa state, near the border with Cameroon, to try to rebuild their lives. For VOA, Chris Stein traveled to the area and has this report.
    Video

    Video Slow Rebuilding Amid Boko Haram Destruction in Nigeria’s Northeast

    Military operations have chased Boko Haram out of towns and cities in Nigeria’s northeast since early last year. But it is only recently that people have begun returning to their homes in Adamawa state, near the border with Cameroon, to try to rebuild their lives. For VOA, Chris Stein traveled to the area and has this report.
    Video

    Video Clinton Leads Trump, But Many Voters Don't Like Either

    In the U.S. presidential race, most recent polls show Democrat Hillary Clinton with a steady lead over Republican Donald Trump as both presumptive party nominees prepare for their party conventions next month. Trump’s disapproval ratings have risen in some recent surveys, but Clinton also suffers from high negative ratings, suggesting both candidates have a lot of work to do to improve their images before the November election. VOA National correspondent Jim Malone has more from Washington.
    Video

    Video New US Ambassador to Somalia Faces Heavy Challenges

    The new U.S. envoy to Somalia, who was sworn into office Monday, will be the first American ambassador to that nation in 25 years. He will take up his post as Somalia faces a number of crucial issues, including insecurity, an upcoming election, and the potential closure of the Dadaab refugee camp in Kenya. VOA’s Jill Craig asked Somalis living in Kenya’s capital city Nairobi how they feel about the U.S. finally installing a new ambassador.
    Video

    Video At National Zoo, Captivating Animal Sculptures Illustrate Tragedy of Ocean Pollution

    The National Zoo in Washington, D.C., is home to about 1,800 animals, representing 300 species. But throughout the summer, visitors can also see other kinds of creatures there. They are larger-than-life animal sculptures that speak volumes about a global issue — the massive plastic pollution in our oceans. VOA's June Soh takes us to the zoo's special exhibit, called Washed Ashore: Art to Save the Sea.
    Video

    Video Baghdad Bikers Defy War with a Roar

    Baghdad is a city of contradictions. War is a constant. Explosions and kidnappings are part of daily life. But the Iraqi capital remains a thriving city, even if a little beat up. VOA's Sharon Behn reports on how some in Baghdad are defying the stereotype of a nation at war by pursuing a lifestyle known for its iconic symbols of rebellion: motorbikes, leather jackets and roaring engines.
    Video

    Video Melting Pot of Immigrants Working to Restore US Capitol Dome

    The American Iron Works company is one of the firms working to renovate the iconic U.S. Capitol Dome. The company employs immigrants of many different cultural and national backgrounds. VOA’s Arman Tarjimanyan has more.
    Video

    Video Testing Bamboo as Building Material

    For thousands of years various species of bamboo - one of the world's most versatile plants - have been used for diverse purposes ranging from food and medicine to textiles and construction. But its use on a large scale is hampered because it's not manufactured to specific standards but grown in the ground. A University of Pittsburgh professor is on track to changing that. VOA’s George Putic reports.
    Video

    Video Orphanage in Iraqi City Houses Kids Who Lost their Parents to Attacks by IS

    An orphanage in Iraqi Kurdistan has become home to scores of Yazidi children who lost their parents after Islamic State militants took over Sinjar in Iraq’s Nineveh Province in 2014. Iraqi Kurdish forces backed by the U.S. airstrikes have since recaptured Sinjar but the need for the care provided by the orphanage continues. VOA’s Kawa Omar filed this report narrated by Rob Raffaele.
    Video

    Video Re-Opening Old Wounds in a Bullet-Riddled Cultural Landmark

    A cultural landmark before Lebanon’s civil war transformed it into a nest of snipers, Beirut’s ‘Yellow House’ is once again set to play a crucial role in the city.  Built in a neo-Ottoman style in the 1920s, in September it is set to be re-opened as a ‘memory museum’ - its bullet-riddled walls and bunkered positions overlooking the city’s notorious ‘Green Line’ maintained for posterity. John Owens reports from Beirut.
    Video

    Video Brexit Resounds in US Presidential Contest

    Britain’s decision to leave the European Union is resounding in America’s presidential race. As VOA’s Michael Bowman reports, Republican presumptive nominee Donald Trump sees Britain’s move as an affirmation of his campaign’s core messages, while Democrat Hillary Clinton sees the episode as further evidence that Trump is unfit to be president.
    Video

    Video NASA Juno Spacecraft, Nearing Jupiter, to Shed Light on Gas Giant

    After a five-year journey, the spacecraft Juno is nearing its destination, the giant planet Jupiter, where it will enter orbit and start sending data back July 4th. As Mike O'Sullivan reports from Pasadena, California, the craft will pierce the veil of Jupiter's dense cloud cover to reveal its mysteries.
    Video

    Video Orlando Shooting Changes Debate on Gun Control

    It’s been nearly two weeks since the largest mass shooting ever in the United States. Despite public calls for tighter gun control laws, Congress is at an impasse. Democratic lawmakers resorted to a 1960s civil rights tactic to portray their frustration. VOA’s Carolyn Presutti explains how the Orlando, Florida shooting is changing the debate.

    Special Report

    Adrift The Invisible African Diaspora