News / USA

    Supreme Court Split in 'Bizarre' First Amendment Case

    FILE - The exterior of the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington.
    FILE - The exterior of the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington.

    The U.S. Supreme Court appeared divided Tuesday during oral arguments in what one justice termed a "bizarre" case between a New Jersey town and a former police officer who contends he was demoted as political payback.

    The nation's highest court has never ruled on whether the right of free speech and association, guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution's First Amendment, prohibits the government from taking action against an employee based on its mistaken perception that he is asserting a political position.

    But that's what happened to Jeffrey Heffernan, a 20-year police veteran in Paterson, N.J., who was spotted picking up a yard sign supporting an opposition candidate during the run-up to the city's 2006 mayoral election.

    Heffernan said the sign was going to be put in the yard of his bedridden mother, who wanted it there to replace one that had been stolen. The policeman said he had no role in the election campaign, although he was a close friend of the candidate.

    Heffernan, who has since left the Paterson force, was not even eligible to vote in the city, since he lived elsewhere.

    Still, word spread of Heffernan's supposedly open political support for mayoral challenger Lawrence Spagnola.

    The police chief and his executive officer — Heffernan's direct supervisor — supported the incumbent mayor, Jose Torres, who was running for re-election.

    Heffernan, newly promoted to detective the year before, was quickly reassigned to foot patrol for "overt involvement in a political election."

    He sued, contending his First Amendment rights had been violated, and a federal jury initially awarded Heffernan $105,000 in damages.

    But the judge retroactively recused himself, citing a conflict of interest, and the case was ultimately thrown out because Heffernan admitted he did not actively campaign for Spagnola or assert his political views. Two different trial judges and appellate panels ruled he could not invoke free speech protections because he was not actually exercising his rights.

    Heffernan appealed to the Supreme Court.

    The nine justices, who will rule on the case this year, appeared split over whether Heffernan was even exercising his First Amendment rights during the 2006 incident.

    "This is a bizarre case, that comes to [the court] on the assumption that he is completely politically apathetic," argued Paterson's lawyer, Tom Goldstein, who contended that Heffernan could have a case under New Jersey's collective bargaining agreements or civil rights laws, but not under the Constitution.

    "It is bizarre," agreed Justice Antonin Scalia, known for his conservative positions on many legal matters. Justice Samuel Alito called the case "highly artificial."

    But Heffernan's lawyers said the former policeman's demotion would have a "chilling effect" on political association everywhere unless the earlier court rulings were rejected.

    They said if the ruling were left to stand, the government could fire any employee just on the belief — even incorrect — that he was a Democrat or Republican, causing the person to worry about misperceptions of his political views or actions.

    Justice Elena Kagan took that position one step further.

    She asked the city's lawyers if they believed a newly elected Democrat, for example, could dismiss "every person without a well-known political view, every couch potato out there," changing the entire character of the office, because the official preferred one political view over another.

    "Part of the reason we have these [First Amendment] protections is because we worry the government is doing things for impermissible reasons ... that the government wants to create a world of speech in which everybody agrees with it and nobody opposes it," Kagan said.


    Mark Snowiss

    Mark Snowiss is a Washington D.C.-based multimedia reporter.  He has written and edited for various media outlets including Pacifica and NPR affiliates in Los Angeles. Follow him on Twitter @msnowiss and on Google Plus

    You May Like

    Self-doubt, Cultural Barriers Hinder Cambodian Women in Tech

    Longtime Cambodian tech observer Sok Sikieng says that although more women have joined profession in recent years, there remain significant factors hindering women from reaching tech potential

    Trans-Adriatic Pipeline to Boost European Energy Security

    $4.5 billion-pipeline will become operational in 2020 and will deliver gas from Azerbaijan’s Shah Deniz II field to southern Italy

    Video California Celebration Showcases Local Wines, Balloons

    Annual festival showcases the region's harvested agriculture, fine wines and offers opportunities to experience the gentle breeze in a hot air balloon flight

    This forum has been closed.
    Comments
         
    There are no comments in this forum. Be first and add one

    Featured Videos

    Your JavaScript is turned off or you have an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.
    Vietnamese-American Youth Optimistic About Obama's Visit to Vietnami
    X
    Elizabeth Lee
    May 22, 2016 6:04 AM
    U.S. President Barack Obama's visit to Vietnam later this month comes at a time when Vietnam is seeking stronger ties with the United States. Many Vietnamese Americans, especially the younger generation, are optimistic Obama’s trip will help further reconciliation between the two former foes. Elizabeth Lee has more from the community called "Little Saigon" located south of Los Angeles.
    Video

    Video Vietnamese-American Youth Optimistic About Obama's Visit to Vietnam

    U.S. President Barack Obama's visit to Vietnam later this month comes at a time when Vietnam is seeking stronger ties with the United States. Many Vietnamese Americans, especially the younger generation, are optimistic Obama’s trip will help further reconciliation between the two former foes. Elizabeth Lee has more from the community called "Little Saigon" located south of Los Angeles.
    Video

    Video First-generation, Afghan-American Student Sets Sights on Basketball Glory

    Their parents are immigrants to the United States. They are kids who live between two worlds -- their parents' homeland and the U.S. For many of them, they feel most "American" at school. It can be tricky balancing both worlds. In this report, produced by Beth Mendelson, Arash Arabasadi tells us about one Afghan-American student who seems to be coping -- one shot at a time.
    Video

    Video Newest US Citizens, Writing the Next Great Chapter

    While universities across the United States honor their newest graduates this Friday, many immigrants in downtown Manhattan are celebrating, too. One hundred of them, representing 31 countries across four continents, graduated as U.S. citizens, joining the ranks of 680,000 others every year in New York and cities around the country.
    Video

    Video Vietnam Sees Strong Economic Growth Despite Incomplete Reforms

    Vietnam has transformed its communist economy to become one of the world's fastest-growing nations. While the reforms are incomplete, multinational corporations see a profitable future in Vietnam and have made major investments -- as VOA's Jim Randle reports.
    Video

    Video Qatar Denies World Cup Corruption

    The head of Qatar’s organizing committee for the 2022 World Cup insists his country's bid to host the soccer tournament was completely clean, despite the corruption scandals that have rocked the sport’s governing body, FIFA. Hassan Al-Thawadi also said new laws would offer protection to migrants working on World Cup construction projects. VOA's Henry Ridgwell reports.
    Video

    Video Infrastructure Funding Puts Cambodia on Front Line of International Politics

    When leaders of the world’s seven most developed economies meet in Japan next week, demands for infrastructure investment world wide will be high on the agenda. Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s push for “quality infrastructure investment” throughout Asia has been widely viewed as a counter to the rise of Chinese investment flooding into region.
    Video

    Video Democrats Fear Party Unity a Casualty in Clinton-Sanders Battle

    Democratic presidential front-runner Hillary Clinton claimed a narrow victory in Tuesday's Kentucky primary even as rival Bernie Sanders won in Oregon. Tensions between the two campaigns are rising, prompting fears that the party will have a difficult time unifying to face the presumptive Republican nominee, Donald Trump. VOA national correspondent Jim Malone has more from Washington.
    Video

    Video Portrait of a Transgender Marriage: Husband and Wife Navigate New Roles

    As controversy continues in North Carolina over the use of public bathrooms by transgender individuals, personal struggles with gender identity that were once secret are now coming to light. VOA’s Tina Trinh explored the ramifications for one couple as part of trans.formation, a series of stories on transgender issues.
    Video

    Video Amerikan Hero Flips Stereotype of Middle Eastern Character

    An Iranian American comedian is hoping to connect with American audiences through a film that inverts some of Hollywood's stereotypes about Middle Eastern characters. Sama Dizayee reports.
    Video

    Video Budding Young Inventors Tackle City's Problems with 3-D Printing

    Every city has problems, and local officials and politicians are often frustrated by their inability to solve them. But surprising solutions can come from unexpected places. Students in Baltimore. Maryland, took up the challenge to solve problems they identified in their city, and came up with projects and products to make a difference. VOA's June Soh has more on a digital fabrication competition primarily focused on 3-D design and printing. Carol Pearson narrates.

    Special Report

    Adrift The Invisible African Diaspora