Accessibility links

Cardinal Faces Sex Abuse Charges in Australia, a Grim Reminder for His Hometown


Colorful ribbons can be seen tied to the fence outside St. Patrick's Cathedral, a spontaneous gesture to remember victims of Roman Catholic church abuse, in the town of Ballarat, located west of the southern city of Melbourne in Australia, July 23, 2017.

One of the pope's top advisers, Cardinal George Pell, makes his first court appearance in Australia this week on charges of historic sex crimes, a bitter reminder for his home town reeling from more than a dozen abuse cases.

Pell, the Vatican's economy minister, last month became the most senior Catholic to be charged with sex crimes. He has vowed to fight the still-unspecified charges, calling them false and the result of a "relentless character assassination."

He declined to respond to interview requests for this story.

He is expected to appear before Melbourne Magistrates' Court on Wednesday.

Cardinal George Pell arrives to make a statement, at the Vatican, June 29, 2017.
Cardinal George Pell arrives to make a statement, at the Vatican, June 29, 2017.

Police have not released details of the charges, but the start of Pell's court battle in Melbourne revisits a troubled past for Ballarat, the former gold town of 100,000 people 75 miles (120 km) to the west where Pell grew up and cut his teeth as a priest in the 1970s and 1980s.

Before a 2013 state government inquiry into institutional abuse, Ballarat was best known to Australians as the site of the Eureka Stockade, a bloody 1854 uprising by gold miners against colonial authorities.

But the government inquiry exposed shocking accounts of child abuse and allegations of a cover-up in the Ballarat diocese over many generations, sparking a more powerful federal Royal Commission that heard testimony from hundreds of people, including allegations against 17 priests in Ballarat alone.

At least five priests from the diocese have been jailed for abuse. Supporters of the victims have tied hundreds of colorful ribbons to the fence outside the city's main Catholic church, St. Patrick's.

Pell, 76, testified at both inquiries, mostly about his knowledge of the handling of complaints against the church when he was a young priest in the 1970s and 1980s. He repeatedly denied direct knowledge of practices which, according to the testimony of others, involved moving suspect priests between parishes to avoid detection.

Neither inquiry heard complaints against Pell himself.

Victoria state police, which brought the charges against Pell last month, haven't said where the charges originated and haven't offered any detail other than that they were for multiple historic sex offenses.

Police declined to comment on specific charges. The Royal Commission, which will deliver its final report to the government later this year, also declined to comment.

Local resident Reiny Strybosch stands outside the St. Patrick's Cathedral in Cardinal George Pell's hometown, just days before the Vatican treasurer's first court appearance on historic sex charges, in the town of Ballarat, located west of the southern city of Melbourne in Australia, July 24, 2017.
Local resident Reiny Strybosch stands outside the St. Patrick's Cathedral in Cardinal George Pell's hometown, just days before the Vatican treasurer's first court appearance on historic sex charges, in the town of Ballarat, located west of the southern city of Melbourne in Australia, July 24, 2017.

"The important thing is that the result of it will be truth and justice, no matter what the truth is," said Reiny Strybosch, who has lived in Ballarat since 1956, on his way to Mass.

Closed Hearing

For Pell, like the city he grew up in, the charges are a reminder of the past. His rise through the Australian clergy paused in 2002, a year after taking the country's top Catholic role as Archbishop of Sydney, when he was accused of abusing two boys at a youth camp in the 1960s.

Pell strongly denied the accusation and took leave to fight it. The church then ran a closed hearing in a Melbourne hotel room, overseen by a retired judge who found that the alleged victim seemed to be telling the truth but that there was insufficient evidence to substantiate the complaint.

The 2002 accuser has not spoken publicly since.

Pell went on to became the Vatican's first economy minister in 2014 as Pope Francis sought to end financial scandals.

Thousands of miles away, the Royal Commission rolled on, with much attention on Ballarat. Data released by the inquiry showed Ballarat was the diocese with the most alleged perpetrator priests after major cities Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane.

Ballarat had more alleged perpetrator priests than Perth, a city of 2 million, according to the data.

Ballarat had 3 percent of Australian Catholic abuse complaints since 1950, despite having just 0.4 percent of the country's population. Reuters was unable to independently confirm the data.

Before he was charged, Pell's seniority and political connections had made him a target for many abuse survivors' frustration about what they believed was reluctance by church and government to listen.

When Pell said in 2016 that he wanted to give evidence from Rome via videolink because he was too sick to fly home, a group of survivors, mostly from Ballarat, traveled to Italy to watch him testify in person.

Peter Blenkiron and Philip Nagle react as they sit in a cafe in Cardinal George Pell's hometown, just days before the Vatican treasurer's first court appearance on historic sex charges, in the town of Ballarat, located west of the southern city of Melbourne, Australia, July 24, 2017.
Peter Blenkiron and Philip Nagle react as they sit in a cafe in Cardinal George Pell's hometown, just days before the Vatican treasurer's first court appearance on historic sex charges, in the town of Ballarat, located west of the southern city of Melbourne, Australia, July 24, 2017.

Now that Pell is to appear before the court, some of those survivors say they want the cardinal treated like any other member of the church accused of sex crimes.

"I can't see any reason that he won't get a fair and just trial," said abuse survivor Philip Nagle, an agronomist. "I'd like to see the claimants get a fair and just trial too."

XS
SM
MD
LG