Accessibility links

Breaking News

Bereaved Blaze Families Criticize Putin for Not Meeting Them


People gather to honor the victims of Sunday's fire in a shopping mall in the Siberian city of Kemerovo, in the center of Moscow, March 27, 2018. Several Russian cities including Moscow are holding rallies to commemorate the dead.

The families of those who died in a massive shopping mall blaze Sunday in the Siberian city of Kemerovo are criticizing President Vladimir Putin for failing to meet with them when he visited the scene of the fire that left at least 64 dead — 41 of them children.

While Putin visited some injured survivors in the hospital, that failed to placate critics. Commentators are branding his visit “cynical,” saying he repeated his mistakes of 18 years ago when he was slow to meet families of sailors who drowned in 2000 when the nuclear submarine the Kursk sank.

A man in the crowd at a Moscow vigil for those who died in a shopping mall blaze March 25 in the Siberian city of Kemerovo offers an indication of protest, March 27, 2018. Opposition figure Alexei Navalny appeared earlier at the vigil, and there were chants for Russian President Vladimir Putin to resign. Police were keeping a close watch. (J. Dettmer/VOA)
A man in the crowd at a Moscow vigil for those who died in a shopping mall blaze March 25 in the Siberian city of Kemerovo offers an indication of protest, March 27, 2018. Opposition figure Alexei Navalny appeared earlier at the vigil, and there were chants for Russian President Vladimir Putin to resign. Police were keeping a close watch. (J. Dettmer/VOA)

“The children are dead already, we can't bring them back. But we need clear justice,” said a traumatized father of a child who died in the massive fire that’s shocked Russia.

He was speaking to hundreds of protesters, who 48 hours after the blaze had come to mourn their dead collectively — and to call angrily for the city’s mayor and regional leaders to resign.Kemerovo sits in a hardscrabble coal-mining region and is no stranger to unexpected tragedy and loss. This time, though, with many children dead there is no sense of acceptance — tempers are flaring with anger mounting as details emerge about how the emergency exits were blocked or locked, preventing quick flight and obstructing rescue efforts.

Still photo taken from video provided by Russian Emergencies Ministry shows a site of a fire at a shopping mall in Kemerovo, Russia March 25, 2018.
Still photo taken from video provided by Russian Emergencies Ministry shows a site of a fire at a shopping mall in Kemerovo, Russia March 25, 2018.

The alarm system failed to work, as did the facility’s PA system, possibly switched off for reasons unknown by a security guard, say investigators. Mall workers fled as the fire swept through the upper floors of the Winter Cherry shopping mall, leaving behind many children trapped in the center’s cinema complex.

President Putin, fresh from re-election, clearly tried get out ahead of the outrage.

On Tuesday, he arrived in Kemerovo, laid flowers at a makeshift memorial, met with with regional authorities and vowed to get to the bottom of what happened. He denounced carelessness and criminal negligence.

But the Russian leader’s avoidance of the bereaved families and protesters complaining about building code violations and shoddy construction angered locals. One woman told the crowd: “We’re asking for the governor, we’re asking for Putin. Why are we being lied to?” She added, according to a local news site: “We give the government their mandate. Let them resign.”

Neither President Putin nor Kemerovo’s regional governor, Aman Tuleyev, addressed the crowd.

Some analysts compared Putin’s visit to Kemerovo with British Prime Minister Theresa May’s first trip to the scene last year of the Grenfell apartment-block fire in London.

Russian President Vladimir Putin lays flowers at a memorial made for the victims of a fire in a multi-story shopping center in the Siberian city of Kemerovo, about 3,000 kilometers (1,900 miles) east of Moscow, Russia, Tuesday, March 27, 2018.
Russian President Vladimir Putin lays flowers at a memorial made for the victims of a fire in a multi-story shopping center in the Siberian city of Kemerovo, about 3,000 kilometers (1,900 miles) east of Moscow, Russia, Tuesday, March 27, 2018.

Seventy-one people died in that blaze, which has been blamed on the building’s cladding, and May was faulted by the media and lawmakers for avoiding angry family members demanding answers and for spending most of her time with officials and first responders.

She went back to the scene several days later in order to placate the families.

As with May, so with Putin.

“Why are the queen and king safe and sound? Let them come here, get up and answer us,” a protester demanded outside Kemerovo’s regional administration, joining others accusing authorities of obscuring the true scale of the disaster, the deadliest fire in the country since the Soviet era.

When Kemerovo’s mayor, Ilya Serduk, appeared there were cries of with cries of “Resign!” and “Murderer!”

People hold portraits of relatives as they gather to remember the victims of a fire in a multi-story shopping center in the Siberian city of Kemerovo, about 3,000 kilometers (1,900 miles) east of Moscow, Russia, March 27, 2018.
People hold portraits of relatives as they gather to remember the victims of a fire in a multi-story shopping center in the Siberian city of Kemerovo, about 3,000 kilometers (1,900 miles) east of Moscow, Russia, March 27, 2018.

Additional riot police and National Guardsmen troops were deployed as the protest developed. Locals have also questioned the official death toll announced by local authorities and they claim that more than 400 people may have died in the fire. “How many people actually died, why are you lying to us?” Interfax agency quoted one protester as shouting.

As he laid flowers in a tribute to the dead, Putin asked: “How could this possibly happen? What's the reason? People, children came to relax. We are talking about demography and are losing so many people because of what? Because of criminal negligence, sloppiness.”

“He laid flowers in a spot cleared of people,” said Olga Bychkova, a presenter for radio station Echo of Moscow. “He met with the heads of the region, he met with some activists or public representatives, but there is a huge crowd standing there in Kemerovo and it seems to me still standing, waiting for an answer from the local authorities. Putin did not approach these people.”

Bychkova told VOA there is a sense of deja vu with the visit.

A woman approaches a memorial in Pushkin Square near the Kremlin, March 27, 2018, to those who died in a massive shopping mall blaze March 25 in the Siberian city of Kemerovo. A few hundred people were present at the vigil, though earlier there were a couple thousand at the site. (J. Dettmer/VOA)
A woman approaches a memorial in Pushkin Square near the Kremlin, March 27, 2018, to those who died in a massive shopping mall blaze March 25 in the Siberian city of Kemerovo. A few hundred people were present at the vigil, though earlier there were a couple thousand at the site. (J. Dettmer/VOA)

In 2000, Putin remained vacationing at his residence in the Back Sea resort of Sochi as the Kursk drama unfolded. The submarine sank in the Barents Sea on the 97th day of his first term in office with 118 seamen on board and he left for his holiday after being assured by navy chiefs a rescue operation was underway and everything was under control.

He eventually met the relatives as a media storm erupted — and the meeting did not go well as relatives accused him of inaction and the military of incompetence. Some analysts pinpoint the storm over the Kursk as triggering Putin’s decision to bring the media to heel and to orchestrate a crackdown on independent television channels.

Bychkova says Putin’s visit to Kemerovo suggests he didn’t fully learn lessons from the sinking of the Kursk. “No, I do not think so. It does not look like that. To start with, he went to Kemerovo more than 24 hours late. Nearly two days have passed since the time all that happened. That is actually a long time! Because already on Sunday night, Moscow time it became clear that something very serious and very scary had happened,” she said.

Your opinion

Show comments

XS
SM
MD
LG