Accessibility links

Breaking News

Trump High Court Nominee on Track as Senate Hearing Wraps Up

(L-R) Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, Sen. Cory Booker, D-N.J., and Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, confer on the last day of the Senate Judiciary Committee's confirmation hearing for President Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominee, Brett Kavanaugh, on Capitol Hill in Washington, Sept. 7, 2018.

Brett Kavanaugh, President Donald Trump's U.S. Supreme Court pick, on Friday appeared on track for Senate confirmation after a four-day hearing in which he avoided any major stumbles even as Democrats tried furiously to derail his nomination.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, asked by conservative host Hugh Hewitt in an MSNBC interview if he had any doubts about Kavanaugh's confirmation, replied: "None whatsoever."

McConnell predicted that Kavanaugh, the conservative federal appeals court judge picked by Trump for a lifetime job on the top U.S. judicial body, would be on the Supreme Court when it opens its new term on October 1.

Trump's fellow Republicans control the Senate by a narrow margin. With no sign of any Republicans planning to vote against Kavanaugh, he seemed poised to win confirmation despite Democratic opposition.

"I think he made a very compelling case that he is one of the most qualified nominees, if not the most qualified, that we've seen for the Supreme Court of the United States, and I think I've seen 15 of them," said Republican Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, who oversaw the hearing and has served in the Senate since 1981.

Kavanaugh completed two days of lengthy questioning by senators on Thursday night, keeping his composure under intense questioning by Democrats. Kavanaugh is likely to push the conservative-leaning court further to the right, if confirmed.

In its final day of the hearing, the committee on Friday heard from outside witnesses testifying for and against the nomination, with protesters again interrupting the proceedings in opposition to Kavanaugh.

Among those testifying were two representatives of the American Bar Association, the leading U.S. professional group for lawyers, who said a panel that rates judicial nominees gave Kavanaugh a "well qualified" rating.

"We gave him the highest rating possible," said Paul Moxley, head of the ABA's Standing Committee on the Federal Judiciary. Trump picked Kavanaugh, 53, to replace Justice Anthony Kennedy, who announced his retirement in June. After the Judiciary Committee votes on the nomination in the coming weeks, a final Senate vote is expected later in the month.

Genial demeanor

During his grueling testimony, Kavanaugh maintained a genial demeanor, blunting some of the most aggressive questioning from Democrats seeking to unsettle him. He trod a careful line when it came to Trump. He refused to be drawn into political controversies and avoided comment on matters such as whether a president can pardon himself or must respond to a subpoena or whether he would recuse himself from cases involving Trump.

On divisive issues that could reach the court such as abortion and gun rights, Kavanaugh declined to offer personal views, restricting himself to reciting Supreme Court precedent. Kavanaugh signaled respect for the landmark 1973 Roe v. Wade Supreme Court ruling legalizing abortion nationwide, calling it an important legal precedent that had been reaffirmed by the
justices over the decades.

Democrats continued to paint Kavanaugh as a threat to abortion rights.

Under questioning by Democratic Senator Kamala Harris, New York University School of Law professor Melissa Murray said that even if he does not back overturning Roe, if Kavanaugh joins fellow conservatives on the high court in upholding a succession of restrictive state laws it could mean "death by a thousand cuts" to a woman's right to an abortion. In refusing to engage on Trump, Kavanaugh declined even to condemn the president's persistent criticism of the federal judiciary.

The president's first appointee to the high court, Neil Gorsuch, last year told senators Trump's remarks on the judiciary were "disheartening" and "demoralizing." The Washington Post reported in December that Gorsuch's comments had angered Trump and that he had privately considered yanking the nomination.

Asked by Democratic Senator Cory Booker on Wednesday whether he was picked because of an expectation of loyalty to Trump, Kavanaugh responded, "My only loyalty is to the Constitution. I'm an independent judge."

Kavanaugh also refused to say whether he had "the greatest respect" for Trump, a phrase Booker said the nominee had used when describing Republican former President George W. Bush, for whom he worked as a White House aide more than a decade ago before Bush appointed him as a judge.